Legal Analyst Defends Netanyahu Amid Reports of UAE Warning
Translated & summarized from Srugim by baba
Legal journalist Aviad Gringauz has dismissed reports that Prime Minister Netanyahu was warned by the UAE president about the October 7th Hamas attack, calling the claims a "journalistic duck." While the UAE did not deny a conversation, they stated they do not comment on media speculation, emphasizing their role in de-escalation and open communication with Israel.
The story in 5 lines · by baba
- Legal journalist Aviad Gringauz disputes reports of a UAE warning to Netanyahu before Oct 7.
- Gringauz calls the reports a "journalistic duck" lacking logic.
- US administration reportedly unaware of any specific UAE warning.
- UAE did not deny a conversation but declined to comment on speculation.
- UAE stated its consistent efforts to de-escalate and maintain open communication with Israel.
Legal journalist Aviad Gringauz has publicly challenged reports claiming that Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu received a specific warning from the UAE president about an impending Hamas attack before October 7th. Gringauz described the initial report by Shlomi Eldar as a "journalistic duck" lacking internal logic. He further criticized the reliance on a previously denied and factually inconsistent report from October 9, 2023, by Smadar Peri, suggesting it was being presented as absolute truth three years later to bolster Eldar's narrative.
Earlier reports from i24News, citing two sources familiar with the matter, indicated that the Biden administration was unaware of any concrete warning from the UAE regarding Hamas's planned large-scale attack prior to October 7th. These sources also stated that the administration had not heard of such a specific UAE warning even after the October 7th events. However, the lack of awareness within the Biden administration does not preclude the possibility that such a warning was conveyed to Israeli officials.
The original report in "Haaretz" alleged that UAE President Mohamed bin Zayed spoke with Netanyahu about a week and a half before the October 7th attack, warning him that Yahya Sinwar was planning a significant move against Israel. According to the report, the UAE president sought to alert Netanyahu to a development that could lead to bloodshed and regional instability. The "Haaretz" report also claimed that Netanyahu believed the potential move concerned the West Bank and that Israeli security officials were not informed of this alleged warning.
The UAE's Ministry of Foreign Affairs issued a statement that did not deny the conversation took place but stated the government does not comment on media stories or speculation regarding leadership discussions. The statement emphasized the UAE's consistent efforts since October 7th to de-escalate tensions, promote regional stability, and prevent violence. It also confirmed that the UAE government and Israeli government officials maintain open and direct communication channels, and relevant intelligence has been and continues to be shared as needed.
Mentioned
The same event, reported separately by each outlet. Open a few to compare what different newsrooms emphasize — and what they leave out.
Left 2Centre 9Right 5Haredi 3Arab 5Other 8
