Criticism Mounts Over IDF General Bar Kalifa’s Appointment Amid October 7 Failures

The planned appointment of Major General Dado Bar Kalifa as head of the IDF Central Command has sparked significant controversy, focusing largely on political issues. However, the core concerns relate to Bar Kalifa’s performance during the October 7 attacks and the handling of subsequent investigations. The article argues that instead of replacing the current Central Command chief, Major General Avi Blot, Defense Minister Yoav Gallant and the IDF Chief of Staff should pause, thoroughly investigate the allegations, and reveal the full truth.

Central Command is one of the most sensitive IDF commands, responsible for security in the West Bank and protecting a wide range of settlements from various terror threats. The commander’s role involves direct implementation of political directives, often absorbing criticism for decisions made by the political echelon. Avi Blot is described as a highly professional and dedicated officer, though not without flaws, and questions are raised about his handling of Jewish terrorism threats, stone-throwing incidents, administrative detentions, and whether he fully learned the lessons of October 7.

Bar Kalifa, who previously commanded the 36th Armored Division, is recognized for leading combat operations in Gaza and Lebanon. Yet, the article highlights his critical failure on October 7, when he did not assume operational command in the field during the Hamas surprise attack, failing to secure any settlements or key positions. Additionally, Bar Kalifa allegedly concealed details in his own investigation, including a controversial incident where he reportedly shot dead two fallen paratroopers and filmed the act, and another where a staff officer was killed during an uncoordinated operation in Kibbutz Be’eri.

The author, retired Brigadier General Oren Solomon, calls for Bar Kalifa to admit mistakes, resign, and set an example of accountability for IDF commanders. He also urges the Defense Minister and Chief of Staff to stop ignoring the October 7 failures and to commission a comprehensive, transparent investigation to restore trust and strengthen Israel’s security. Solomon criticizes the Defense Minister for four errors: seeking to replace Blot, appointing Bar Kalifa despite his failures, announcing the appointment on television, and the timing amid a sensitive period in the West Bank.

The article concludes with a call for truth and justice, quoting Psalms to emphasize the need for transparency and integrity in military leadership, especially in light of the tragic events of October 7.