Get Plus

Sign in to baba News

One account across the web, iPhone and Android — your subscription follows it.

or use an email code

Search stories

Type at least two characters. Results come from every newsroom baba reads.

↑↓ to move · ↵ to open · esc to close

Sign in to baba News

Sign in to keep asking. News Plus removes the daily limit.

or use an email code

Ongoing Story· Today

Supreme Court Orders Retrial for Gynecologist Convicted of Rape Amid Procedural Dispute

2 developments

YnetSecurity

Supreme Court Justice Orders Retrial for Gynecologist Convicted of Rape

Translated & summarized from Ynet by baba

CenterCharged tone

Hebrew · 10 newsrooms covering

The Deputy President of the Supreme Court, Justice Noam Sohlberg, ordered a retrial for Dr. Michael Stettman, convicted of fraud-related rape. Sohlberg cited a "real concern of a miscarriage of justice" due to a misunderstanding regarding the state's withdrawal of sexual offense charges. The original conviction did not reflect the state's withdrawal, leading to a flawed premise. Attempts to resolve the issue through agreement failed, prompting Sohlberg's decision to grant the retrial, emphasizing the system's ability to correct errors.

The story in 6 lines · by baba

  • Supreme Court Justice Noam Sohlberg ordered a retrial for Dr. Michael Stettman, convicted of fraud-related rape.
  • Sohlberg cited a "real concern of a miscarriage of justice" in the original proceedings.
  • The conviction was based on a flawed premise regarding the state's withdrawal of sexual offense charges.
  • The original ruling did not reflect the state's unconditional withdrawal of its request.
  • Attempts to reach an agreement for resolution failed, leading to the retrial order.
  • Sohlberg stated a retrial shows the justice system's ability to correct significant errors.
Supreme Court Justice Orders Retrial for Gynecologist Convicted of Rape
Editorial illustration generated by baba News, not a photograph of the event.

Deputy President of the Supreme Court, Justice Noam Sohlberg, has ordered a retrial for Dr. Michael Stettman, a gynecologist previously convicted of defrauding and raping his patients. The retrial will take place before a five-judge panel to be determined by President Yitzhak Amit.

Sohlberg stated that the unusual circumstances of the original proceedings raised a "real concern of a miscarriage of justice" by the previous Supreme Court justices, Yechiel Katcher, Yosef Elron, and Alex Stein, leading him to grant the retrial request. Stettman had initially been acquitted unanimously by the District Court of the sexual offenses. The state appealed this acquittal, seeking a conviction.

During the appeal hearing, Supreme Court justices suggested considering a conviction for assault. Following this, the state informed the court in writing that it was withdrawing its request to convict Stettman of sexual offenses, while simultaneously proposing a conviction for assault. Approximately six months later, Stettman was convicted of fraud-related rape by the Supreme Court.

Crucially, the original conviction ruling did not mention the state's withdrawal of its request for sexual offense charges. Sohlberg emphasized that the state's withdrawal was "unconditional" at the time, meaning it was not contingent on Stettman agreeing to an assault conviction. He argued that the conviction was based on a flawed premise regarding the validity and nature of the prosecution's notification. The discrepancy, revealed in a Ynet report, was that the state's withdrawal was not reflected in the conviction judgment, as if it never occurred.

Sohlberg clarified that a retrial does not determine guilt or innocence but rather whether the conviction stands on solid ground. He found Stettman's understanding of the proposal made during the hearing, though later proven incorrect, to be "not unreasonable." He also noted that the state appeared to have understood the proposal similarly, and there was no "cohesion of interests" between the state and the defense to explain this shared understanding.

The decision also addressed attempts to avoid further proceedings. Sohlberg mentioned his and Justice Khaled Kabub's prior efforts to reach agreements that would resolve the dispute and shorten the process. He believed the matter should have been settled by mutual understanding rather than a judicial decision imposing a retrial "like a mountain." However, these attempts failed, with the State Attorney refusing to agree to a proposed framework. Even when Sohlberg convened the State Attorney for a hearing, he remained firm in his position.

With no agreement reached, Sohlberg undertook the task of making a decision. After reviewing the pleadings, protocols, recordings, and judgments, he concluded that the request should be granted. He stated that there was no point in trying to determine who was responsible for the "communication breakdown" in the proceedings; the key question was whether the cumulative circumstances created a genuine concern of a miscarriage of justice. Sohlberg stressed that a retrial demonstrates the justice system's ability to self-examine and correct significant errors, asserting that nothing damages public trust more than the perception that the judiciary is closed off to correcting wrongful convictions.

YnetCentre · Rishon LeZion

Sign in to baba News

Sign in to follow newsrooms, topics and people.

or use an email code

Sign in to baba News

Sign in to follow newsrooms, topics and people.

or use an email code

Mentioned

Open the Wire