Supreme Court Orders Retrial Due to Judicial Error
Translated & summarized from N12 by baba
Israel's Supreme Court has ordered an unprecedented retrial for gynecologist Michael Shtetman, who was convicted of rape. Deputy President Noam Sohlberg cited judicial error and unfairness as the reasons for the retrial, which will be held at the Supreme Court. The decision came after the same panel of judges convicted Shtetman of rape, despite recommending the prosecution withdraw its appeal against his acquittal on that charge. Shtetman's lawyer praised the ruling, calling it an important recognition of the possibility of error within the justice system.
The story in 6 lines · by baba
- Supreme Court orders retrial for gynecologist Michael Shtetman due to judicial error.
- Deputy President Noam Sohlberg cited miscarriage of justice and unfairness in the conviction.
- The original conviction for rape occurred despite judges recommending prosecution withdraw appeal.
- Sohlberg acknowledged the justice system is human and fallible, not perfect.
- State Prosecutor Amit Isman was summoned but failed to reach a settlement.
- The retrial will be held unusually at the Supreme Court before five judges.
In an unprecedented move, Israel's Supreme Court has ordered a retrial for a gynecologist, Michael Shtetman, who was convicted of raping his patients. Deputy President of the Supreme Court, Noam Sohlberg, ruled that a miscarriage of justice and unfairness occurred due to an error by the judges who convicted Shtetman.
The Supreme Court justices had convicted Shtetman of rape, despite having previously recommended that the prosecution withdraw its appeal against his acquittal by a lower court. The prosecution had accepted the recommendation to pursue a lesser charge of assault instead of rape, but the same panel of judges proceeded to convict him of rape.
Sohlberg stated in his ruling that the conviction was based on a mistaken assumption about the prosecution's notification. He emphasized that the justice system, being human, is not infallible and can make mistakes. "The justice system is human, not heavenly. As such, it is not free from error or mistake, it is not perfect, nor can it be, but 'only' effective," he wrote.
Sohlberg also noted that he had unprecedentedly summoned the State Prosecutor, Amit Isman, to a hearing to avoid a retrial and encourage a settlement, but this was unsuccessful. Due to the unusual circumstances, Sohlberg decided to order a retrial.
The retrial will unusually take place at the Supreme Court before a five-judge panel, as the error originated from the Supreme Court itself. Shtetman's attorney, Yeniv Vaki, welcomed the decision, stating it recognizes that errors can occur in the justice system and must be corrected, particularly in criminal proceedings, to ensure a fair trial.
Shtetman's legal team had consistently argued that an injustice had occurred and insisted on rectifying the conviction, especially when a person's right to a fair trial was compromised.
Mentioned
The same event, reported separately by each outlet. Open a few to compare what different newsrooms emphasize — and what they leave out.
Left 1Centre 5Right 2Other 2
Not the same event — other stories that share this one’s people, places, or theme: background, reactions, and follow-ups.
