developing· Security· Updated
Supreme Court Orders Retrial for Gynecologist Convicted of Rape Amid Procedural Dispute
The Supreme Court has ordered a retrial for gynecologist Michael Shtetman, who was convicted of fraud-related rape on appeal after having been acquitted by a lower court. The decision, announced on Thursday, November 19, 2026, follows a procedural dispute and what was described as a communication breakdown between the parties and the court during the appeal process.
4 newsrooms · 2 languages · sinceWhat happened
- 01The Supreme Court ordered a retrial for gynecologist Michael Shtetman, who was convicted of fraud-related rape on appeal.
- 02Shtetman was previously acquitted of all sexual offenses by the Jerusalem District Court in December 2022.
- 03During the appeal, the prosecution agreed to withdraw sex offense charges and seek an assault conviction instead.
- 04The Supreme Court unanimously convicted Shtetman of rape in March 2025 despite the prosecution's revised request.
- 05Deputy President of the Supreme Court Justice Noam Sohlberg cited a communication breakdown and mistaken assumptions as grounds for the retrial.
- 06An expanded panel of five Supreme Court justices will hear the retrial to correct the judicial error.
Shtetman, a gynecologist since 1999, was indicted in December 2018 on charges of performing sexual acts on patients during medical treatments under the guise of necessary examinations. In December 2022, or January 2023 according to Arutz Sheva and Ynetnews, the Jerusalem District Court unanimously acquitted him of multiple sexual offenses, finding no criminal intent. The state appealed the acquittal to the Supreme Court.
During an appeal hearing in September 2024, the justices proposed convicting Shtetman of assault instead of rape. Both the prosecution and defense understood that sex offense convictions were no longer being pursued, and the state subsequently indicated it was withdrawing its request for a sex offense conviction. However, in March 2025, the Supreme Court unanimously convicted Shtetman of fraud-related rape, citing a disagreement between the prosecution and the defense.
Following the conviction, which surprised the prosecution, the state did not oppose a retrial. Deputy President of the Supreme Court Justice Noam Sohlberg ordered the retrial, noting a mistaken assumption regarding the prosecution's notice. The case will now be heard by an expanded panel of five Supreme Court justices.
Summarized by baba from the reports of 4 newsrooms. Updated
Latest report: Arutz Sheva. Read Arutz Sheva’s originalThe coverage
4 newsrooms on this story
Who covered it
- Left1
- Centre2
- Right1
- HarediNone
- ArabNone
How it broke
How the headlines differ
Supreme Court Orders Retrial for Gynecologist Convicted of Rape Amid Procedural Dispute
