Get Plus

Sign in to baba News

One account across the web, iPhone and Android — your subscription follows it.

or use an email code

Search stories

Type at least two characters. Results come from every newsroom baba reads.

↑↓ to move · ↵ to open · esc to close

Sign in to baba News

Sign in to keep asking. News Plus removes the daily limit.

or use an email code

Ongoing Story· Today

Supreme Court Orders Retrial for Gynecologist Convicted of Rape Amid Procedural Dispute

2 developments

VestyPolitics

Supreme Court Orders Retrial for Gynecologist Convicted of Rape

Translated & summarized from Vesty by baba

CommunityNeutral tone

Russian · 10 newsrooms covering

Deputy President of the Supreme Court Noam Sohlberg ordered a retrial for gynecologist Michael Statman, who was convicted of rape. Statman was initially acquitted but the prosecution appealed. Sohlberg cited a "real concern of a miscarriage of justice" due to a communication breakdown where the prosecution withdrew its sexual offense charge but this was not noted in the final verdict. The retrial aims to ensure the conviction is sound, reflecting the court's ability to correct errors.

The story in 6 lines · by baba

  • Supreme Court Justice Noam Sohlberg ordered a retrial for gynecologist Michael Statman convicted of rape.
  • Sohlberg cited a "real concern of a miscarriage of justice" in the original proceedings.
  • Statman was initially acquitted, but the prosecution appealed the decision.
  • The prosecution withdrew its sexual offense charge, but this was not mentioned in the final verdict.
  • The retrial will examine the validity of the conviction before a five-judge panel.
  • Sohlberg stated the retrial shows the justice system's ability to correct significant errors.
Supreme Court Orders Retrial for Gynecologist Convicted of Rape
Editorial illustration generated by baba News, not a photograph of the event.

Deputy President of the Supreme Court Noam Sohlberg has ordered a retrial for a gynecologist, Michael Statman, who was convicted of raping patients. The decision, issued on Thursday, November 19, came in response to a petition filed by the convicted doctor.

Statman had initially been unanimously acquitted by the Jerusalem District Court on charges of sexual offenses. However, the prosecution appealed the acquittal, seeking a conviction from the Supreme Court. The retrial will be heard by a five-judge panel at the Supreme Court, to be determined by President Yitzhak Amit.

Sohlberg cited exceptional circumstances in the case that raised a "real concern of a miscarriage of justice." He identified potential errors made by Supreme Court Justices Yechiel Kasher, Yosef Elron, and Alex Stein, who presided over the initial appeal. Consequently, Sohlberg granted the petition.

During the appeal hearing, Statman's representatives, Professor Yaniv Wacman and Advocate Irit Baumhor, were present. The justices had suggested considering a conviction for assault. Following this, the prosecution formally withdrew its demand for a sexual offense conviction and instead requested a conviction for assault. Approximately six months later, the Supreme Court convicted Statman of rape, without noting the prosecution's change in demand.

Sohlberg emphasized that the prosecution's withdrawal of the sexual offense charge was "unconditional." He noted that the discrepancy, where the original conviction's ruling did not mention the prosecution's withdrawal, only came to light later during the review of a request to overturn the verdict. "There is no mention" of the withdrawal in the verdict, Sohlberg stated, adding that the fact was "absent from the verdict, as if it never happened."

The majority judges' reasoning for convicting Statman despite the withdrawal was only provided retrospectively during the review of the cancellation request, and these arguments did not form the basis of the original verdict. Sohlberg clarified that the retrial's purpose is not to determine guilt or innocence but to verify the robustness of the conviction.

He acknowledged that Statman might have reasonably interpreted the judges' proposal during the hearing, even though he later understood it incorrectly. The decision also touched upon attempts to avoid a new trial. Sohlberg, like Justice Khaled Kabub before him, had tried to broker a settlement between the parties to resolve the dispute and shorten the proceedings. He believed a mutual agreement would have been preferable to a court decision necessitating a retrial. However, these efforts failed, as the State Prosecutor, Amit Ishman, remained steadfast even after a meeting in the Supreme Court chamber.

With no agreement reached, Sohlberg stated, "the duty to bring the matter to a conclusion falls upon me." After reviewing documents, transcripts, and rulings, he concluded that the petition should be granted. He deemed it unnecessary to investigate who was responsible for the "communication breakdown" during the proceedings, focusing instead on whether the totality of circumstances created a genuine concern of a miscarriage of justice. Sohlberg stressed that the retrial demonstrates the judicial system's capacity for self-examination and correction of significant errors, stating, "There is nothing that harms public trust in justice more than the feeling that justice has closed its doors and locked them against any possibility of correcting an unlawful verdict."

VestyOther · Tel Aviv

Sign in to baba News

Sign in to follow newsrooms, topics and people.

or use an email code

Sign in to baba News

Sign in to follow newsrooms, topics and people.

or use an email code

Mentioned

Open the Wire