Supreme Court Orders Retrial Due to Judicial Error
Translated & summarized from Mako by baba
Israel's Supreme Court has ordered an unprecedented retrial for gynecologist Michael Shtetman, acknowledging a judicial error led to his rape conviction. Deputy President Noam Sohlberg cited a miscarriage of justice due to the court's mistaken premise in convicting Shtetman after recommending the prosecution withdraw its appeal. The retrial will be held at the Supreme Court, and Shtetman's attorney hailed the decision as a crucial correction of a legal error.
The story in 5 lines · by baba
- Supreme Court orders retrial for Michael Shtetman due to judicial error.
- Deputy President Noam Sohlberg cited a miscarriage of justice and unfairness.
- Justices convicted Shtetman of rape despite recommending prosecution withdraw appeal.
- Sohlberg stated the justice system is human and not immune to mistakes.
- The retrial will be held unusually at the Supreme Court before five judges.
In an unprecedented move, Israel's Supreme Court has ordered a retrial for a gynecologist convicted of raping his patients, acknowledging a significant error made by the court itself. Deputy President Noam Sohlberg ruled that the conviction of Michael Shtetman was based on a flawed premise and resulted in a miscarriage of justice.
Sohlberg stated that the Supreme Court justices had convicted Shtetman of rape despite having previously recommended that the prosecution withdraw its appeal against his acquittal by a lower court. The prosecution had accepted this recommendation and sought to convict him of a lesser charge of assault, but the same panel of justices proceeded to convict him of rape.
"The justice system is not immune to error," Sohlberg wrote in his ruling, emphasizing that judges are human and can make mistakes. He noted that the court's decision to convict Shtetman was based on a mistaken assumption about the prosecution's statement. The retrial will be held unusually at the Supreme Court before a five-judge panel, as the error originated from the Supreme Court itself.
Sohlberg also revealed that he had unprecedentedly summoned the State Attorney, Amit Isman, to a hearing to avoid a retrial and seek a compromise, but no agreement was reached. Shtetman's attorney, Yeniv Vaki, welcomed the decision, calling it an important recognition that mistakes can occur in the justice system and must be corrected to ensure a fair trial.
Shtetman had appealed for a retrial after the Supreme Court justices convicted him of rape, contradicting their earlier recommendation to the prosecution to drop the appeal against his acquittal. The original trial court had acquitted him of the rape charge.
Mentioned
The same event, reported separately by each outlet. Open a few to compare what different newsrooms emphasize — and what they leave out.
Left 1Centre 5Right 2Other 2
Not the same event — other stories that share this one’s people, places, or theme: background, reactions, and follow-ups.
