Israeli Security Establishment Surprised by Netanyahu's Rejection of Gaza Withdrawal Plan

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu surprised the security establishment by abruptly rejecting the 15-point peace council plan involving partial Israeli withdrawals in Gaza. Despite previously attending discussions on limited pullbacks in three areas near Rafah, Netanyahu announced on August 9, 2026, that Israel would not proceed with any withdrawal until Hamas is fully disarmed. The security officials said they only learned of Netanyahu's change of stance through media reports, as he had earlier approved the plan in meetings that included IDF Chief of Staff Eyal Zamir.

The debated pilot involved replacing Israeli Defense Forces (IDF) troops with a multinational force in three Rafah-adjacent zones, coordinated with American officials. Discussions also covered the operational interface between the IDF and the multinational force, specifying where Israeli troops would withdraw and remain. Netanyahu emphasized that Israel is negotiating with the U.S. on disarming Hamas, accepting some American proposals but rejecting others, and vowed that the IDF would continue to thwart threats against Israeli forces and civilians.

This reversal marks a significant shift from prior government deliberations, highlighting internal disagreements and the complexities of security policy in Gaza. Netanyahu's firm stance underscores Israel's insistence on Hamas's complete disarmament before any territorial concessions. The security establishment now faces uncertainty as it adapts to the prime minister's unexpected decision.