MK Shapiro Condemns Minister for Sending Her Critical Post About Her Deceased Son
Translated & summarized from Kan News by baba
Member of Knesset Shira Shapiro publicly criticized a government minister for sending her a harsh social media post that compared her political views to her son's actions on October 7, who was killed that day. Shapiro stated the minister privately shared the post, written by Natanel Glasner, questioning how such words could be sent to a bereaved mother. She emphasized the need for respectful discourse, even amidst deep disagreements, and asserted that her love for Israel and the sacrifices made by her family are unquestionable.
The story in 5 lines · by baba
- MK Shira Shapiro criticized a minister for sending her a critical post about her deceased son.
- The post by Natanel Glasner compared Shapiro's son's actions to her political views.
- Shapiro stated the post accused her of supporting those who want to destroy Israel.
- She argued that using her son's memory to criticize her is cruel and unacceptable.
- Shapiro called for respectful debate and for remembering basic humanity.
Member of Knesset Shira Shapiro, whose son Anar was killed on October 7, revealed on Sunday that a government minister had personally sent her a critical social media post targeting her. Shapiro, a member of the "Yashar" party, stated on Facebook that the minister had privately shared the post, written by Natanel Glasner, explaining it was important for her to read.
The post, titled "Mother Versus Son," compared Shapiro's son's actions on October 7 to her own political stances. Glasner accused the MK of supporting those who "give encouragement to her son's murderers" and of handing "the keys of the Knesset to those who seek to annihilate the State of Israel." He further claimed she was complicit in "tearing the country apart from within and endangering its very existence," even if done "with statesmanship, with substance, and in a non-inflammatory tone." The author concluded by contrasting "historical insignificance and irresponsibility" with "historical heroism and self-sacrifice."
Shapiro questioned how a minister could deem it appropriate to send such words to a bereaved mother. She also shared that she, her family, and her colleague Elissafer Peretz and his family have been receiving harsh messages. While acknowledging the pain, anger, and fear in Israeli society, Shapiro emphasized the need for respectful debate, even during deep disagreements, and for criticism without demonizing others.
She clarified that she does not seek immunity from criticism due to her family's tragedy but stressed that there are boundaries. "There is something particularly cruel in trying to pit a bereaved mother against her fallen son," she stated, adding that speaking in her son's name and using his memory to question her motherhood is unacceptable. Shapiro addressed the minister who sent the post, urging him to consider his intentions, even if he did not write the content himself. She concluded by asserting that her love for the country and the price her family paid for it are beyond doubt, and that the least owed to her son is to remember how to be human.
The same event, reported separately by each outlet. Open a few to compare what different newsrooms emphasize — and what they leave out.
Centre 3Right 4Haredi 1
Not the same event — other stories that share this one’s people, places, or theme: background, reactions, and follow-ups.
