Minister Sends Bereaved MK Post Accusing Her of Aiding Her Son's Killers
Translated & summarized from Maariv by baba
Minister of Diaspora Affairs Amichai Chikli sent a post to MK Shira Shapira that compared her to her son, Aner Shapira, who died on October 7th. The post accused Shapira of aiding her son's killers and undermining Israel. Shapira, a bereaved mother, revealed the harsh messages her family has received, questioning the minister's actions and stressing the need for respectful discourse despite political disagreements. She stated that while she doesn't seek immunity from criticism, her love for Israel and her family's sacrifice should not be questioned.
The story in 5 lines · by baba
- Minister Amichai Chikli sent MK Shira Shapira a post comparing her to her son Aner, killed Oct. 7.
- The post accused Shapira of aiding her son's murderers and undermining Israel.
- Shapira, a bereaved mother, revealed the harsh messages her family has received.
- She questioned how a minister could send such words to a grieving mother.
- Shapira stressed the need for respectful discourse despite deep political disagreements.
Minister of Diaspora Affairs Amichai Chikli sent a post to Member of Knesset Shira Shapira that compared her to her son, Aner Shapira, who fell on October 7th. Shapira, a bereaved mother, revealed the harsh messages her family has been receiving in recent weeks, including this post sent to her personally after Shabbat.
The post, which Chikli clarified he was not sharing but wanted her to read, accused Shapira of aiding those who wish to harm Israel and of preferring Israel's enemies over her own brothers. It drew a stark contrast between her son Aner's heroism in confronting "absolute evil" and Shapira's political stances and actions, stating she "chooses to stand with those who give encouragement to the murderers of her son."
Further accusations in the post claimed Shapira was part of those who "handed over the keys of the Knesset to those who aspire to eliminate the State of Israel" and was complicit in "tearing the country apart from within and endangering its very existence." It directly compared the bereaved mother to her fallen son, calling her "misery and irresponsibility on a historic scale" versus his "heroism and self-sacrifice on a historic scale."
Shapira responded by questioning how an Israeli minister could deem it appropriate to send such words to a mother who lost her son defending the country. She acknowledged the pain and anger in Israeli society but stressed the need for respectful discourse, even amidst deep disagreements. While not seeking immunity from criticism due to her loss, she stated there are boundaries that should not be crossed, particularly when her son's memory is used to question her positions and loyalty.
She emphasized that while political differences are valid, they should not be used to doubt her love for Israel or her family's heavy sacrifice. "The least we owe him is not to forget how to be human beings," Shapira concluded, reflecting on her son's death for the sake of the nation's survival.