MK Accuses Minister of Sending Cruel Post Comparing Her to Fallen Son
Translated & summarized from Arutz Sheva by baba
Member of Knesset Shira Shapira revealed that a government minister sent her a harsh post comparing her to her son, who fell on October 7. The post, written by Natanel Glasner, accused Shapira of supporting those who wish to harm Israel. Shapira stated that while criticism is acceptable, using her son's memory in this manner is cruel and unacceptable. She emphasized the need for respectful discourse even amidst deep political divides, concluding that her love for Israel and the sacrifices made should not be questioned.
The story in 6 lines · by baba
- MK Shira Shapira revealed a minister sent her a post comparing her to her son killed on Oct 7.
- The post accused Shapira of supporting those who harm Israel and tearing the country apart.
- Shapira called the comparison cruel and unacceptable, stating "there is a limit."
- She stated her bereavement should not prevent criticism but objected to using her son's memory.
- The post was written by internet user Natanel Glasner and titled "Mother vs. Son."
- Shapira urged Israelis to remember humanity even during political disagreements.
Member of Knesset Shira Shapira revealed that a government minister personally sent her a post written by an internet user, which harshly compared her to her son, Aner, who was killed on October 7. Shapira stated, "There is something particularly cruel about trying to pit a bereaved mother against her fallen son."
Shapira recounted on Saturday evening that one of the government ministers sent her a post authored by a user named Natanel Glasner. The post launched a sharp attack on her political activities and drew a comparison between her and her son, Aner Shapira, who fell on October 7. According to Shapira, the minister clarified that he was not sharing the post himself but felt it was important for her to see its contents. Shapira did not reveal the minister's identity.
"At the end of Shabbat, one of the government ministers chose to personally send me this post. He clarified that he was not sharing it, but it was important for him that I read the words," she wrote. She described the content of the message she received: "Words accusing me, a bereaved mother, of complicity in tearing the country apart, of preferring Israel's enemies over my brothers, and of giving encouragement to those who seek to harm our country."
Shapira expressed her dismay, questioning how a situation arose where a minister would think it appropriate to forward such words to a mother who lost her son defending the country. She noted that recently, she and her family, along with her friend Elisafeh Peretz and his family, have been receiving harsh messages due to political disagreements. "I understand the pain, anger, and fear engulfing Israeli society. But even within the harshest disagreements, we must know how to debate without trampling and criticize without turning the other into an enemy," she stated.
She emphasized that her bereavement should not shield her from criticism of her public activities, but she objected to the use of her son's memory in such criticism. "I am not asking for immunity from criticism because of the tragedy that befell my family. But there is a limit," she asserted. "There is something particularly cruel in trying to pit a bereaved mother against her fallen son. To speak in Aner's name, to dictate what he would have believed and use his memory to cast doubt on my faith." Shapira added, "When a minister in Israel chooses to forward such words, even if he did not write them himself, he should ask himself what he sought to achieve. One can disagree with my path, but my love for the country and the price we paid for it, no one will question."
She concluded her remarks by saying, "My Aner paid with his life so we could continue to live here together. The least we owe him is not to forget how to be human beings." The post sent to Shapira was written by Natanel Glasner and began with the title "Mother vs. Son." Glasner wrote, "Aner Shapira stood with his body against absolute evil. With unimaginable bravery and supreme self-sacrifice, he risked his life to save others from the monsters of humanity who came to murder Jews." He went on to accuse Shapira of "choosing to stand with those who encourage the murderers of her son." He added, "She is complicit in tearing the country apart from within and in endangering its very existence, but she does so with stateliness, with substance, and in a non-inflammatory tone. Exactly as she promised from the Knesset podium. Because apparently, one can also lead to destruction politely." The post concluded with another comparison between mother and son: "Mother vs. Son. Abjectness and irresponsibility on a historic scale, versus bravery and self-sacrifice on a historic scale."
