UN Envoy Apologizes for Misinterpreting Nazi Term, Holocaust Denial Accusations
Translated & summarized from Ynet by baba
UN Special Rapporteur Francesca Albanese apologized for misinterpreting the Nazi-era term "Muselmann" and the origin of "antisemitism," after facing criticism from Yad Vashem and others for historical revisionism. She admitted the term "antisemitism" was coined to mean hatred of Jews, not all Semitic peoples, and that "Muselmann" described starving prisoners, not a specific group linked to Muslims.
The story in 5 lines · by baba
- UN envoy Francesca Albanese apologized for misinterpreting Nazi terms and the origin of antisemitism.
- She admitted "Muselmann" described starving prisoners, not a link between Jews and Muslims.
- Albanese also corrected her assertion that "antisemitism" originally meant hatred of all Semitic peoples.
- Yad Vashem condemned her initial remarks as dangerous historical revisionism.
- Critics accused her of a pattern of distorting history and anti-Israel bias.
Francesca Albanese, the UN Special Rapporteur on the situation of human rights in the Palestinian territories, has admitted to misinterpreting the term "Muselmann," used in Nazi concentration camps to describe prisoners in extreme states of exhaustion and starvation. She also acknowledged an error in her assertion that the term "antisemitism" originally referred to hatred of all Semitic peoples, clarifying that it was coined to denote hatred of Jews.
Albanese's apology followed strong criticism from Yad Vashem, Israel's Holocaust memorial, which condemned her remarks as "clear and dangerous historical revisionism." Earlier in the month, in an interview, Albanese had suggested that Jews were referred to as "Muselmänner" when being led to gas chambers, presenting this as part of a broader argument that "antisemitism" initially encompassed non-Europeans from the Middle East before focusing on Jews. She described it as a "heartless racist hatred of non-whites, non-pure, and non-Christians" that evolved into hatred of Jews, while also stating that hatred of Jews "as Jews" is severe but should not be confused with criticism of Israel.
Yad Vashem rejected her claims, stating that Albanese was attempting to "reshape the persecution and murder of Jews by the Nazis as part of a broader hatred." The institution asserted that her description of the history and term "antisemitism" was fundamentally flawed, as the term explicitly referred to hostility towards Jews from its inception. Yad Vashem emphasized that "Muselmann" was not exclusively used for Jews and did not imply a Nazi connection between Jews and Muslims. According to the memorial, the term originated among prisoners, not Nazis, to describe any severely emaciated prisoner, regardless of religion, who was near death.
The Auschwitz-Birkenau Memorial Museum noted that "Muselmann" in German described prisoners suffering extreme exhaustion and starvation in Auschwitz and other camps, with its origin unclear and not a Nazi racial classification. Prisoners so described often died soon after or were selected for execution. The International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA) states that "antisemitism" was coined in 1879 by German journalist Wilhelm Marr and has always referred to prejudice against Jews. The term "Semitic" refers to a language group, not a racial or national group.
In her apology on X, Albanese stated, "I misread the term 'Muselmann,'" leading to her incorrect conclusion about the original meaning of "antisemitism." Israel's Ambassador to the UN, Danny Danon, criticized Albanese, calling her a "Holocaust denier" and accusing her of a pattern of distorting history to promote her anti-Israel agenda, urging the UN to remove her from her post. UN Watch also commented on X, stating that Albanese "cannot name hatred of Jews without substituting Jews."
Mentioned