Get Plus

Sign in to baba News

One account across the web, iPhone and Android — your subscription follows it.

or use an email code

Search stories

Type at least two characters. Results come from every newsroom baba reads.

↑↓ to move · ↵ to open · esc to close

Sign in to baba News

Sign in to keep asking. News Plus removes the daily limit.

or use an email code

Zman YisraelPolitics

US Firmness Offers Chance to Save Zionist Vision

Translated & summarized from Zman Yisrael by baba

CenterCharged tone

Hebrew · 1 newsroom

A shift in US policy towards Israel, moving from unconditional support to a partnership based on shared interests and conditions, presents an opportunity for Israel to secure its future, according to Nadav Tamir. This change, driven by growing American fatigue with Middle East conflicts and a reassessment of US interests, necessitates progress on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, including the establishment of a demilitarized Palestinian state. The article argues that this approach, rather than abandonment, can save Israel from prolonged conflict and isolation, urging Israelis to take responsibility for shaping their nation's future.

The story in 5 lines · by baba

  • US policy shift from unconditional support to conditional partnership offers Israel a chance to secure its future.
  • Growing American fatigue with Middle East conflicts necessitates a new strategy for US-Israel relations.
  • Progress on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, including a demilitarized Palestinian state, is a key condition for future US support.
  • This policy change is seen as an opportunity to save Israel from prolonged conflict and isolation.
  • Israelis are urged to take responsibility for shaping their nation's future direction.

Many Israelis fear the political shift in the United States, worrying about a loss of American support, military operational constraints, and political pressure impacting Israel's security. However, this change could present a significant opportunity for Israel's future if managed correctly. For decades, Washington provided nearly unconditional support, including diplomatic backing, advanced weaponry, and substantial financial aid. The article questions whether this policy has truly made Israel safer, citing the ongoing military occupation, the West Bank's descent into annexation, the inability of the IDF to stop Jewish terrorism, and Hamas's continued existence despite Gaza's devastation.

Furthermore, open fronts in Lebanon and Syria, coupled with Israel's increasing isolation, pose a strategic danger. The conflict with Iran, which has not eliminated the nuclear threat, has exacerbated American fatigue with Middle East military involvement. The mid-term election results and subsequent criticism highlighted the war's political burden on the US administration, with many Americans questioning the rationale and benefit of costly Middle East wars. Increasingly, segments of the American public and political system view Israel as a driver of this involvement.

A consensus is forming in Washington, across both Democratic and Republican parties, that a new strategy for relations with Israel is needed. This emerging understanding identifies the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, and specifically the Israeli government's refusal to address its resolution, as a primary cause of regional instability and a detriment to American and allied interests. Consequently, support for Israel is expected to transition from unconditional backing to a partnership based on shared interests, values, and clear conditions, notably progress toward a demilitarized Palestinian state within a regional settlement.

This shift is not an abandonment of Israel but a potential path to save it from a future of occupation, isolation, and endless conflict. The traditional US policy has enabled Israeli governments to repeatedly postpone crucial decisions. Unconditional support, the author argues, does not always serve Israel's long-term interests and can allow governments to pursue risky policies without paying a strategic price. The current moment offers a chance to change course with American diplomatic assistance, securing Israel's future as the democratic nation-state of the Jewish people. The Trump administration's intention to cease direct subsidies for American arms purchases, agreed to by Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, reflects a bipartisan trend. Justifying such subsidies to American taxpayers for a country with a high GDP per capita is becoming increasingly difficult. Israel should gradually move from dependency on US aid to a partnership based on mutual interests.

Future arms deals will be scrutinized, with American conditionality becoming a lever for policies benefiting both nations and the US partnership in the region. While Israel has a vested interest in American commitment to its defense against genuine threats, particularly concerning defensive systems like Iron Dome, the purpose of offensive American weapons sales needs examination. Funding prolonged, costly campaigns that deepen Israel's isolation without providing sustainable security is questioned. Similarly, military force alone is not a viable strategy against Iran; diplomacy, backed by credible military power and an international coalition, is presented as a more effective long-term approach, citing the Obama administration's success with the JCPOA nuclear deal. The US should pursue a deal ensuring strict oversight of Iran's nuclear program in exchange for measured sanctions relief. Concurrently, efforts with Gulf states are needed to secure freedom of navigation in the Strait of Hormuz and halt Iranian proxy aggression. Military action should remain a last resort, not a default option. Strengthening the Lebanese government to dismantle Hezbollah and supporting a stable Syrian regime to prevent Iranian resurgence are also highlighted as beneficial for Israeli security.

The article stresses that beyond military threats, Israel must recognize that without resolving the Palestinian conflict and establishing a Palestinian state, it will face a choice between being the Jewish nation-state and a democracy. Governing millions of Palestinians without national or political rights is unsustainable and will alter the state's character. New settlements and annexation steps push closer to an unmanageable bi-national reality. The US should lead a regional and international effort to establish a demilitarized Palestinian state, supporting its institutions and ensuring free and fair elections conditioned on renouncing violence and terrorism. Old legal barriers between the US and Palestinians should be removed, and efforts with international partners should improve Palestinian governance. Israel is urged to release frozen Palestinian tax revenues, impose targeted sanctions on extremist settlers, and halt settlement expansion and annexation steps.

Regarding Gaza, Washington should lead diplomatic efforts to implement the Trump and Mladenov plans, involving Hamas's gradual disarmament with regional assistance, phased Israeli withdrawal, and the transfer of security and governance to legitimate Palestinian entities. Only a credible political settlement, ensuring Gaza does not revert to a terror base, will enable Gulf states and the international community to invest in the Strip's reconstruction. Immediate aid to Gaza's residents is also crucial to prevent further suffering and reduce hostility. Ultimately, the US should present Israel with a clear choice: integration into the region, peace with neighbors including a demilitarized Palestinian state, economic and security cooperation, and international acceptance, versus continued occupation, conflict, annexation, and deepening isolation. Choosing settlement will preserve Israel's identity as a democratic Jewish nation-state and offer future generations a future not based on endless war, fulfilling the founders' vision. True support for Israel involves helping it achieve security, peace, equality, and democracy, not giving a blank check to any government or policy. Israel needs a strong and courageous America willing to speak the truth, but the responsibility for change ultimately lies with Israelis themselves.

Zman YisraelCentre · Jerusalem

Sign in to baba News

Sign in to follow newsrooms, topics and people.

or use an email code

Sign in to baba News

Sign in to follow newsrooms, topics and people.

or use an email code

Mentioned

Open the Wire