Legal Advisor Questions Conscription Plan's Legality
Translated & summarized from N12 by baba
The legal advisor to the Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee, Miri Frankel-Shore, believes Avigdor Lieberman's proposed conscription law may face legal challenges due to its leniency towards the Haredi community. Lieberman denies a specific "Lieberman plan" exists, stating his parameters involve approval from the IDF Chief of Staff, Supreme Court, and Rabbi Dov Lando. The ongoing negotiations aim to resolve a political deadlock over military conscription for Haredi men.
The story in 5 lines · by baba
- Legal advisor Miri Frankel-Shore doubts the legality of Avigdor Lieberman's proposed conscription law.
- Frankel-Shore cites the plan's leniency towards the Haredi community as a legal obstacle.
- Avigdor Lieberman denies the existence of a specific "Lieberman plan" for conscription.
- Lieberman states any new law must pass approval from the IDF Chief of Staff, Supreme Court, and Rabbi Dov Lando.
- No concrete proposal has yet emerged to resolve the political deadlock over Haredi conscription.
The legal advisor to the Knesset's Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee, Adv. Miri Frankel-Shore, has expressed concerns in closed-door discussions that the proposed conscription law framework, reportedly being negotiated by Avigdor Lieberman, may not pass legal scrutiny. Frankel-Shore previously opposed several clauses in a prior conscription exemption bill proposed by former committee chairman MK Boaz Bismuth, arguing that Lieberman's current proposal is more lenient towards the Haredi community and therefore less likely to meet legal standards. She reportedly sees no legal justification or change in military needs that would warrant a different legal approach compared to Bismuth's bill.
Despite ongoing talks, no concrete proposal has emerged that satisfies the demands of Rabbi Dov Lando, the Supreme Court (Bagatz), and the IDF Chief of Staff, while also resolving the political deadlock. Lieberman, who was recently appointed Chairman of the Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee, has denied the existence of a specific "Lieberman plan," stating that no such document or discussion has taken place. He reiterated his parameters for a new conscription law: it must pass through the Chief of Staff, the Supreme Court, and Rabbi Dov Lando, and he has requested a review of Supreme Court justices' comments on previous conscription proposals.
Lieberman had previously stated that the conscription law he would advance would not be "conscription for everyone," a remark that angered reserve soldiers' organizations. He later clarified that no framework had yet been finalized and that he was unaware of any specific plan being criticized. Earlier in the month, following reports that he was lifting his veto on a government with Haredi parties, Lieberman indicated a willingness to be flexible and compromise on the conscription issue.
Mentioned