Legal Hurdle Emerges for Draft Haredi Draft Law, Lieberman Disputes Report
Translated & summarized from Arutz Sheva by baba
A legal advisor has raised concerns about the legality of a proposed Haredi draft law, stating it cannot be approved based on a 2018 plan by Avigdor Lieberman. Lieberman denied the existence of such a plan, sparking a dispute with reporter Amit Segal, who stood by his reporting. The legal advisor believes current circumstances do not justify a lenient draft law, and no consolidated bill has yet emerged.
The story in 5 lines · by baba
- Legal advisor questions legality of Haredi draft law based on 2018 Lieberman plan.
- Avigdor Lieberman denies existence of a "Lieberman plan" for Haredi draft law.
- Reporter Amit Segal defends his report amid Lieberman's strong denial.
- Legal advisor sought sanctions and deemed current circumstances insufficient for leniency.
- No consolidated draft bill has yet secured agreement from rabbis, politicians, and legal counsel.
A significant legal obstacle has emerged for the developing Haredi draft law, as reported by Amit Segal on Channel 12. The legal advisor to the Knesset's Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee, Miri Frankel-Shore, has indicated that she cannot see a legal basis for approving a draft law based on a previous proposal by Avigdor Lieberman from 2018. This older proposal, which reportedly lacked personal sanctions, is considered more lenient towards the Haredi community than a bill advanced by MK Boaz Bismuth.
Frankel-Shore also expressed reservations about certain clauses in the Bismuth bill, demanding the inclusion of sanctions. According to Segal, it is uncertain whether the bill would have received her approval even with these changes. The legal advisor believes that current legal circumstances and the army's needs do not justify a more lenient draft law.
Segal emphasized that despite recent discussions, no consolidated draft bill has yet been presented that would satisfy rabbis, the political system, and legal counsel. This indicates a lack of a clear path forward for the legislation.
Avigdor Lieberman, chairman of Yisrael Beiteinu, vehemently denied Segal's report, calling it false and stating that no "Lieberman plan" exists. He asserted that he has only presented two principles: that any draft law must pass the approval of the IDF Chief of Staff, the Supreme Court, and the rabbis, and that he requested an analysis of Supreme Court justices' comments on previous draft law petitions.
In response to Lieberman's denial, Segal clarified his position, suggesting Lieberman's stance was disingenuous. Segal argued that advocating for the draft law to be approved by rabbis and based on the 2018 law, which lacked personal sanctions, inherently constitutes a more lenient approach than Bismuth's bill. He further contended that a stricter law than Bismuth's would not gain rabbinical approval, thus validating his original report.
Mentioned
