Get Plus

Sign in to baba News

One account across the web, iPhone and Android — your subscription follows it.

or use an email code

Search stories

Type at least two characters. Results come from every newsroom baba reads.

↑↓ to move · ↵ to open · esc to close

Sign in to baba News

Sign in to keep asking. News Plus removes the daily limit.

or use an email code

i24NEWS ArabicPolitics

US-Israel Debate Over Iran Escalation Driven by Politics, Not Existential Threat

Translated & summarized from i24NEWS Arabic by baba

CenterCharged tone

Arabic · 1 newsroom

Israeli political and media circles are questioning the motives behind Israel's pressure on the U.S. for military action against Iran. Two experts presented contrasting views: Professor Meir Israeli emphasized Iran's "existential" threat to Israel's national security, while Alef Al-Sabbagh argued the escalation is driven by political calculations and Netanyahu's interests. Al-Sabbagh also noted internal U.S. reservations about further wars and China's efforts to promote stability in vital shipping lanes.

The story in 6 lines · by baba

  • Israeli political circles question if Iran escalation is driven by existential threat or political calculations.
  • Professor Meir Israeli views Iran's nuclear program and regional influence as an "existential" threat to Israel.
  • Expert Alef Al-Sabbagh links escalation to political and ideological motives, not solely U.S. interests.
  • Netanyahu is seen as leveraging the situation, with potential political gains for Israel and himself.
  • Internal U.S. administration reservations exist regarding further military involvement in the region.
  • China seeks understandings to reduce mutual losses in energy and shipping routes, opposing U.S. control of Hormuz.
US-Israel Debate Over Iran Escalation Driven by Politics, Not Existential Threat
Editorial illustration generated by baba News, not a photograph of the event.

Fundamental questions are being raised in Israeli political and media circles regarding the true motivations behind increasing Israeli pressure on the U.S. administration to consider military options against Iran. These discussions follow media reports of intensive efforts led by Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and his close associates in Washington, amidst internal divisions within President Donald Trump's administration and significant economic and electoral considerations in the U.S.

A debate on i24NEWS Arabic, titled "Is War on Iran an Israeli Interest or Does Washington's Interest Require Weakening Iran?", presented two opposing viewpoints. Dr. Meir Israeli, a political science professor at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem, focused on Israeli national security and the Iranian threat. Conversely, Alef Al-Sabbagh, a Middle East affairs expert from the Upper Galilee, linked the escalation to political and ideological calculations and international power balances.

Professor Israeli argued that confronting Iran is inseparable from regional national security and Western interests. He identified the Iranian threat as "existential" for Israel due to its declared ideology and support for militias on its borders. He asserted that past military operations to weaken Iran have been insufficient as long as Tehran can pursue nuclear weapons. Israeli dismissed claims that Netanyahu's actions are driven by personal ambition, stating the Prime Minister acts in Israel's and his party's interest, and that convincing Washington is a political gain for Israel. He also suggested that Republican losses in U.S. midterm elections were linked to voter sentiment on oil prices, not a direct vote against war.

Al-Sabbagh offered a critical perspective, suggesting that the push for military confrontation is tied to political and ideological calculations rather than purely American interests. He posited that Netanyahu is leveraging the current situation, supported by elements within the military-industrial complex and the Zionist lobby, to push for a U.S.-involved confrontation, intersecting with Netanyahu's own political future. Al-Sabbagh noted reservations within the Trump administration and the "America First" movement regarding further wars, citing Trump's intervention before an election to prevent an Israeli military move that could have escalated the conflict.

Al-Sabbagh distinguished between an actual military threat from Iran, which he believes Iran lacks the capacity to pose to Israel given Israeli military superiority and international support, and a broader concept of "national security" that links Israel's survival to maintaining its regional military, technological, and political dominance. He also touched upon China's role, explaining that while the U.S. and China compete over energy resources and vital shipping lanes like the Strait of Hormuz, China seeks understandings that minimize mutual losses and opposes U.S. control over the strait, emphasizing the rights and security of littoral states.

i24NEWS ArabicCentre · Jaffa

Sign in to baba News

Sign in to follow newsrooms, topics and people.

or use an email code

Sign in to baba News

Sign in to follow newsrooms, topics and people.

or use an email code

Mentioned

Open the Wire