Israel to Maintain Long Shifts for Doctors in Central Region
Translated & summarized from Vesty by baba
Doctors in central Israel will continue working 26-hour shifts, while a program to shorten shifts will remain exclusive to peripheral hospitals. The Ministry of Health approved recommendations after a three-year pilot, citing resource and system readiness. While doctors in the pilot program report high satisfaction, medical associations criticize the decision as discriminatory. Future nationwide expansion depends on meeting significant staffing and training requirements.
The story in 6 lines · by baba
- Doctors in central Israel will continue working 26-hour shifts, unlike those in peripheral hospitals.
- A pilot program for shorter doctor shifts will remain exclusive to peripheral hospitals.
- The decision was based on resource availability and healthcare system readiness, according to the Ministry of Health.
- Medical associations criticize the decision, calling it discriminatory and advocating for nationwide uniformity.
- Future national expansion of shorter shifts is contingent on meeting specific staffing and training targets.
- Doctors in the pilot program report high satisfaction with reduced workload and improved work-life balance.
Doctors undergoing specialization in central Israel hospitals will continue to work shifts of up to 26 consecutive hours, as the program to shorten working hours, currently in effect at peripheral medical facilities, will not be extended to them. The outgoing Director-General of the Ministry of Health, Moshe Bar Siman-Tov, approved recommendations from a working group that evaluated the shift reduction program. The group, led by Professor Shlomi Kodech, Director of Soroka Medical Center, concluded after nearly three years of the pilot program that shorter shifts will not yet apply to hospitals in central Israel or to additional medical specialties.
The program will remain exclusive to peripheral hospitals with some modifications. This decision has drawn criticism from the medical community, with professional organizations like the Israeli Association of Internal Medicine advocating for uniform working conditions nationwide. The report's authors cited resource availability and healthcare system readiness as reasons for not expanding the program. Future nationwide implementation is contingent on meeting staffing requirements, including issuing at least 2,000 medical practice licenses annually for three consecutive years, totaling 6,000 new doctors, and maintaining adequate staffing ratios in peripheral hospitals and various specialties.
Despite the limited rollout, surveys indicate high satisfaction among doctors already working shorter shifts, which typically involve 19 hours of duty plus 2 hours for handover, compared to the standard 24-hour shifts plus handover. Over 75% of participating residents reported reduced mental strain, burnout, improved concentration, empathy, and a better work-life balance.
The approved recommendations grant hospitals more flexibility in scheduling, allowing shift start times between 11:00 AM and 2:00 PM, with completion the next day between 8:00 AM and 11:00 AM, not exceeding 21 hours total (19+2). However, certain specialties, including adult, pediatric, and neonatal intensive care units, will be excluded, as will specific departments like dermatology, geriatrics, nephrology, rehabilitation, oncology, and hematology, upon hospital request and under certain conditions.
To address the increased workload on senior physicians due to shorter resident shifts, an additional specialist position will be allocated per participating department, with hospitals allowed to substitute this with auxiliary staff temporarily. Senior doctors will also have the option of performing 'half-shifts' to maintain income. Furthermore, efforts will be made to reduce administrative tasks for residents by hiring additional non-medical and support staff, allowing doctors to focus more on patient care and professional development.
The Ministry of Health will establish a dedicated unit to oversee the reform and a professional center to share best practices and prepare for potential national expansion. The working group also suggested reviewing the medical specialization system itself, including residency duration, rotation schedules, and exam procedures, to align with a potential nationwide standard of shorter shifts. Professor Kodech emphasized that the decision was based on three years of experience and the high satisfaction of participating residents, while acknowledging the need for ongoing support and evaluation.
Professor Howard Amital, Chairman of the Israeli Association of Internal Medicine, strongly criticized the Ministry's decision, arguing that the successful pilot program warrants immediate nationwide implementation. He stated that maintaining different working conditions based on hospital location constitutes unacceptable discrimination and that doctors in central Israel should have the same rights as their colleagues in the periphery.
Mentioned
The same event, reported separately by each outlet. Open a few to compare what different newsrooms emphasize — and what they leave out.
Left 1Centre 1Other 2
Not the same event — other stories that share this one’s people, places, or theme: background, reactions, and follow-ups.
