Israel to Maintain Shorter Resident Shifts, But Not Expand Nationwide
Translated & summarized from Calcalist by baba
Israel's Ministry of Health will continue shorter resident shifts, reducing them from 26 to 21 hours, but will not expand the policy nationwide. A committee found residents are satisfied, but senior physicians face increased workload. The new model introduces flexibility by department and recommends adding senior physicians to compensate for the reduced resident hours. The ministry will budget for these changes, prioritizing senior staff additions.
The story in 6 lines · by baba
- Israel's Ministry of Health will maintain shorter resident shifts, reducing them from 26 to 21 hours.
- The shorter shift policy will continue in peripheral hospitals but will not expand to central Israel.
- Residents largely report satisfaction with the shorter shifts, while senior physicians experience increased workload.
- The updated model allows departmental flexibility in shift start times and potential exemptions for certain specialties.
- A key recommendation is adding one senior physician post per department to alleviate senior staff burden.
- The Ministry of Health will budget for these changes, focusing on senior physician additions and implementation oversight.
Israel's Ministry of Health has decided to continue the policy of shorter shifts for medical residents, a reform implemented three years ago that reduced shifts from 26 to 21 hours. The decision, adopted by Director General Moshe Bar Siman Tov based on recommendations from a committee led by Prof. Shlomi Kodech, will maintain the shorter shifts as the default in peripheral hospitals where they are currently in effect. However, the reform will not be expanded to central Israel and will transition from a uniform model to a flexible one across departments.
The committee found that while residents largely reported satisfaction with the shorter shifts, leading to improved quality of life and family time, senior physicians and department heads experienced increased workload and perceived a negative impact on resident training and treatment continuity. Approximately 75% of residents surveyed were satisfied with the current model, while only 12% of senior physicians expressed satisfaction, with over a third calling for a return to the previous system.
To address the challenges, the new model introduces flexibility. Departments will be able to set shift start times between 11:00 AM and 2:00 PM, with the 19-hour shift plus two hours of overlap remaining. Certain departments, including dermatology, geriatrics, nephrology, rehabilitation, oncology, and hematology, may be exempted under specific conditions, such as limiting resident shifts to six per month and ensuring three consecutive hours of sleep. Additionally, the shorter shifts will apply based on the specialty of the rotation rather than the resident's home department.
A key recommendation is the addition of one senior physician post per department to alleviate the burden on existing senior staff, who have absorbed much of the residents' reduced hours. This aims to correct the imbalance created by the original reform, which focused on residents. Departments can opt to convert this senior physician post into support staff positions if preferred.
While the reform will continue, its expansion is deemed premature due to ongoing challenges. The conditions for future expansion, such as an average of 2,000 licensed physicians annually over three years, remain unchanged. The committee also recommended no changes to resident salaries, despite a reported monthly loss of 1,000-1,500 shekels, and noted that the 'quarter shift' for additional income is viewed negatively by residents.
The Ministry of Health is tasked with budgeting and implementing these adjustments, prioritizing the additional senior physician positions and establishing a dedicated management unit and knowledge-sharing body to oversee the process and facilitate continuous learning from the field.
Mentioned
The same event, reported separately by each outlet. Open a few to compare what different newsrooms emphasize — and what they leave out.
Left 1Centre 1Other 2
Not the same event — other stories that share this one’s people, places, or theme: background, reactions, and follow-ups.
