Grosz's Art and Lapid's Film Reflect Societal Decay
Translated & summarized from Jüdische Allgemeine by baba
George Grosz's 1926 painting "The Pillars of Society," depicting societal decay, is featured in Nadav Lapid's film "Yes." Lapid uses the artwork to reflect on an Israeli society brutalized by the October 7th attacks and the Gaza war. The film also critiques post-Soviet nihilism, drawing parallels between contemporary Israel and Russia. The article explores art's role in social commentary and the importance of clear observation during crises.
The story in 6 lines · by baba
- George Grosz's 1926 painting "The Pillars of Society" depicts a world of malice and violence.
- Nadav Lapid's film "Yes" opens with Grosz's painting to portray a brutalized Israeli society.
- The film features a Russian magnate commissioning an anthem for a victorious Israel.
- Both Grosz and Lapid employ biting social satire to critique societal changes.
- The article draws parallels between contemporary Israeli and Russian societies.
- Art's role in social commentary and clear observation during crises is discussed.
George Grosz's 1926 painting "The Pillars of Society" depicts a world of malice, hypocrisy, and violence, a "Germany pandemonium" that eerily foreshadowed the grim reality of the years to come. The painting, now housed at the Neue Nationalgalerie in Berlin, retains its potent dystopian impact a century later. Interest in the apocalyptic and decadent Weimar Republic has surged, evidenced by the TV series "Babylon Berlin" and numerous exhibitions on "New Objectivity" art.
Filmmaker Nadav Lapid's film "Yes" opens with Grosz's "The Pillars of Society," setting a tone for a portrayal of Israeli society wounded and brutalized by the October 7th attacks and the Gaza war, becoming almost amoral. The film features a scene at a Tel Aviv party attended by Israeli military officials and a Russian-born magnate (Alexei Serebrjakow). This magnate later commissions the film's protagonist, Y. (Ariel Bronz), to compose an anthem for a victorious, war-mongering Israel.
Lapid's inclusion of Grosz's work highlights a shared inclination towards biting social satire. The article suggests that Israeli society, like post-Soviet societies, has been altered by mass immigration from the collapsing Soviet empire, not always for the better. The stark contrast of splendor and misery, captured by artists like Grosz, Otto Dix, and Rudolf Schlichter a century ago, serves as a mirror to contemporary times, including the apparent indifference of Russian society to its own atrocities in the ongoing war in Ukraine.
The film's portrayal of the Russian magnate, obsessed with retribution against Gazan Palestinians, reflects a nihilism prevalent since the Soviet Union's fall, influencing even the Kremlin. The article questions Lapid's grotesque exaggeration, pondering art's role in conveying positive messages. It draws a parallel to the Weimar Republic, where alongside sharp social critique, New Objectivity also encompassed apolitical, idyllic themes. While Grosz fled Nazi Germany, other artists remained active, some even benefiting from the departure of their colleagues. The piece concludes that a clear view is essential when the world is aflame.