Bank Leumi CEO Defends Profits, But Who Truly Benefits?
Translated & summarized from Calcalist by baba
Bank Leumi CEO Hanan Friedman defended the bank's high profits, stating they return to the public who are shareholders. However, an analysis reveals that the benefits are concentrated among the wealthy due to unequal income distribution. Israel's banking sector shows significantly higher returns on equity compared to Europe, driven by interest income and limited competition. The introduction of new competitors like Revolut is seen as a potential solution, though challenges remain.
The story in 6 lines · by baba
- Bank Leumi CEO Hanan Friedman stated profits return to the public, who are shareholders.
- Israel's banking sector ROE is 15.7% (2023-2025), far exceeding the EU's 9.3%.
- Income from capital is highly concentrated, with the top decile receiving 48%.
- Net interest income, not fees, is the primary driver of Leumi's profits.
- Revolut received a conditional license to operate a new bank in Israel.
- Limited competition in Israel's banking sector contributes to high profits.
Bank Leumi CEO Hanan Friedman addressed public criticism over the bank's substantial third-quarter profits of approximately 3 billion shekels, from which 1.5 billion shekels were distributed to shareholders. Friedman argued in a video that a significant portion of these profits ultimately returns to the public, as Leumi has no controlling shareholder and its stock is held by the public, directly or through pension and provident funds. This defense aims to preempt backlash against large profits during a period of economic hardship and high cost of living, which has already led to a special tax on banks.
While Friedman's argument that the public benefits holds some truth, as rising bank stocks increase the value of pension savings, the distribution of wealth is highly unequal. Data shows the top income decile receives 48% of income from capital, significantly more than the lower eight deciles combined. This concentration means the benefits of bank profits are not evenly distributed among the public.
The bank's profits are primarily driven by net interest income, which constituted about 72% of Leumi's third-quarter revenue, totaling approximately 4.7 billion shekels. This income stems from the significant spread between interest rates on overdrafts (over 11.5% in July 2026) and the zero interest paid on substantial customer current account balances. Israel's banking system's return on equity (ROE) stood at 15.7% between 2023-2025, considerably higher than the European Union's average of 9.3% during the same period, with Leumi itself reporting an ROE of nearly 17% in the third quarter.
Despite the banks' operational efficiency, evidenced by Leumi's improved efficiency ratio, their services remain expensive. This is attributed to a concentrated market with few major players, limiting competition for retail customers. While profits enable banks to provide credit and fund infrastructure projects, the exceptionally high ROE compared to European banks, which also fund infrastructure, remains unexplained by efficiency alone.
The solution to this issue lies in increasing competition. Bank of Israel has granted a conditional license to Revolut to establish a bank in Israel, the third new bank license since 2019. However, the license is conditional, and the start date for operations is unknown. Furthermore, the performance of other new digital banks, like One Zero, has been financially challenging, and Revolut itself has faced regulatory issues abroad. The leadership of Revolut's Israeli operations will include former Leumi chairman Mooli Ben-Zvi and former Pepper CEO Ori Nathan, raising questions about their ability to challenge the established banking system they came from. Ultimately, the article concludes that banks will not voluntarily relinquish high profits, and genuine competition offering lower-cost services is necessary for the promise of profits returning to the public to have broader meaning.
Mentioned