Judge Reprimanded for Examining Litigant's Cell Phone During Trial
Translated & summarized from Behadrei Haredim by baba
The Commissioner for Complaints against Judges, Asher Kolla, ruled that a judge improperly examined a litigant's cell phone contacts during a civil trial. Kolla stated judges cannot initiate searches of digital devices without explicit requests and the right to be heard. The ruling followed a complaint where the litigant alleged privacy violations and bias. Kolla issued new guidelines for judges on handling digital devices in court.
The story in 6 lines · by baba
- Retired Judge Asher Kolla ruled a judge improperly examined a litigant's cell phone contacts.
- Judges cannot initiate searches of digital devices without explicit requests and the right to be heard.
- The ruling followed a litigant's complaint alleging privacy violations and bias during a civil trial.
- The judge had argued his actions were permitted under rules allowing examination of 'any document'.
- Kolla referenced a Supreme Court ruling emphasizing the privacy implications of smartphone searches.
- New guidelines require judges to avoid independent searches and inform individuals of their right to refuse.
The Commissioner for Complaints against Judges, retired Judge Asher Kolla, has ruled that a judge acted improperly by independently examining a litigant's mobile phone contact list during a civil trial. Kolla stated that judges cannot initiate searches of digital devices belonging to parties or witnesses without an explicit request and an opportunity for the individual to present their case. This ruling came after a litigant filed a complaint, alleging the judge took his phone during a hearing and browsed his contacts without consent, exploiting the power imbalance in court and failing to inform him of his right to refuse. The complainant argued this violated his privacy and demonstrated bias.
The judge, in his response, defended his actions, citing civil procedure rules that allow courts to order the presentation of "any document," which he interpreted to include mobile phones and contact lists. He claimed the examination was necessary to uncover the truth and prevent perjury, as the litigant's testimony appeared unreliable. He also asserted that the right to privacy is not absolute and the inspection was limited to contacts and the dialer.
However, Commissioner Kolla rejected the judge's legal interpretation, deeming the idea that a mobile phone constitutes a "document" subject to unilateral examination as erroneous and overly broad. He referenced a Supreme Court ruling (Bagatz 8298/22) that smartphones contain sensitive personal information, and accessing them infringes on the constitutional right to privacy. Therefore, such actions require explicit legal authorization, not expansive interpretations of document production powers.
In light of this case, Kolla issued guidelines for judges regarding digital devices. Judges should avoid independently searching mobile phones or other digital devices without a specific request and without allowing the owner to argue their case. If information from a device is needed, the judge should instruct the owner to locate and present it themselves, rather than taking the device. Furthermore, judges must proactively inform individuals of their right to refuse to present information and clearly define the scope of any requested examination, acknowledging the inherent power disparity in court.
The same event, reported separately by each outlet. Open a few to compare what different newsrooms emphasize — and what they leave out.
Haredi 2
Not the same event — other stories that share this one’s people, places, or theme: background, reactions, and follow-ups.