Judges Barred From Searching Litigants' Phones Without Consent
Translated & summarized from JDN by baba
Israel's Grievance Commissioner for Judges, Asher Koller, ruled that judges cannot search litigants' or witnesses' digital devices without consent. The decision followed a complaint where a judge browsed a litigant's phone contacts. Koller stated such searches violate privacy rights and require explicit legal authorization. New guidelines mandate judges to avoid independent searches and instead ask owners to present information, while informing them of their right to refuse.
The story in 5 lines · by baba
- Judges cannot independently search litigants' or witnesses' digital devices without consent, ruled Asher Koller.
- The ruling came after a judge browsed a litigant's phone contacts during a civil hearing.
- Commissioner Koller cited privacy rights and a Supreme Court ruling on smartphone data.
- New guidelines require judges to ask owners to present information themselves.
- Parties must be informed of their right to refuse such information requests.
Israel's Grievance Commissioner for Judges, retired Judge Asher Koller, has issued a landmark ruling restricting judges' authority to examine digital devices belonging to litigants and witnesses in court. The decision stems from a complaint filed by a party in a civil case who alleged that during a hearing, the judge took his mobile phone and, without explicit consent, browsed his contact list. The complainant argued this action exploited the inherent power imbalance in court and violated his privacy and judicial fairness, as he was not informed of his right to refuse. The judge, in response, cited civil procedure rules that allow him to order the presentation of "any document," asserting that a mobile phone and its contact list fall under this definition. He claimed his actions were motivated by a duty to uncover the truth after the complainant's testimony appeared unreliable, and that the inspection was limited to contacts and the dialer only.
Commissioner Koller rejected the judge's interpretation, deeming it erroneous and overly broad to consider a mobile phone a "document" for proactive examination. He referenced a Supreme Court ruling (High Court of Justice 8298/22) stating that smartphones contain a person's private life, and accessing them infringes upon the fundamental right to privacy, requiring explicit legal authorization. Consequently, Koller determined the procedure used in the hearing was flawed. Beyond this specific case, Koller established new guidelines for the judiciary: judges must refrain from independently searching digital devices of parties or witnesses unless explicitly requested and the right to argue has been granted. If specific information is needed, the court should instruct the device owner to locate and present it themselves, rather than conducting the search. Furthermore, individuals must be clearly and proactively informed of their legal right to object to presenting information and the boundaries of any potential examination.
The same event, reported separately by each outlet. Open a few to compare what different newsrooms emphasize — and what they leave out.
Haredi 2
Not the same event — other stories that share this one’s people, places, or theme: background, reactions, and follow-ups.