Arab MKs' Refusal to Sing Anthem Shows Disregard for Israel

Professor Aryeh Eldad argues that Arab Knesset members' consistent refusal to stand for the Israeli national anthem, "Hatikvah," demonstrates their fundamental rejection of Israel as a Jewish state. He notes that this practice, where most Arab MKs from the Joint List parties leave the plenum during the anthem, has been ongoing since 2015. Eldad contends that while these MKs may pledge allegiance to Israel, their actions, such as walking out during "Hatikvah," reveal their true stance: they do not recognize Israel's right to exist as a Jewish nation.

Eldad criticizes the "change bloc" in Israeli politics for considering a minority government that could rely on the support of Arab parties. He likens this to a drug dealer offering free samples, suggesting that such political arrangements come with hidden costs and future demands. He warns that any Israeli government should not be dependent on those who refuse to recognize the state's symbols or stand for its anthem, as this grants them veto power over government decisions.

The professor addresses Mansour Abbas, suggesting that while Abbas may "de facto" recognize Israel's existence, he does not acknowledge its "de jure" right to exist. Eldad believes Abbas's willingness to lie, facilitated by the concept of "Taqiyya" (dissimulation), could extend to offering de jure recognition if it serves his purposes. He posits that such recognition would be a lie, offered to those eager for power who are willing to pay for it with legislation, rights, and government positions.

Eldad predicts that a minority government reliant on Arab parties would be short-lived, given the ongoing conflict in the region. He anticipates that circumstances will eventually arise where Arab parties cannot support a government fighting against their brethren. He hopes that voters will learn from leaders who break commitments, suggesting that the price of this lesson should not be too high.