Israeli Visitor Critiques Art Biennale's Anti-Israel Stance
Translated & summarized from Makor Rishon by baba
An Israeli artist couple visiting the Venice Biennale found the art world heavily critical of Israel, with exhibitions focusing on post-colonialism and Palestinian narratives. The author felt that while Palestinian suffering was highlighted, Israeli perspectives, particularly those of settlers, were marginalized or demonized. A meeting with Lorenzo De Castro, director of the International School of Graphics in Venice, led to a discussion where the author identified with Bezalel Smotrich, arguing for a rational and ethical voice for settlers. The author concluded that Europe, while a platform for discourse, offers limited access for Israeli narratives.
The story in 5 lines · by baba
- An Israeli artist visiting the Venice Biennale found the exhibition heavily biased against Israel.
- The Biennale's theme of societal healing was perceived as focusing on post-colonialism and Palestinian narratives.
- The author felt Israeli perspectives, especially those of settlers, were silenced or demonized.
- He identified himself as a settler and declared "I am Smotrich" to a Venetian art school director.
- A Palestinian flag flew over the historical Jewish Ghetto at the Biennale, symbolizing narrative control.
An Israeli artist couple visited the Venice Biennale, finding the central exhibition "In Minor Keys" focused on societal healing, but perceived it as heavily biased against Israel. Upon entering, they encountered a poem by Gazan poet Rafaat Alareer, who was killed in an Israeli bombing, which evoked a sense of guilt about colonialism in viewers. The author noted a significant controversy surrounding Israel at the Biennale, with over 200 artists and cultural figures calling for the boycott of the Israeli pavilion, following a previous instance where Israeli artists delayed opening the pavilion until a ceasefire and hostage deal. The author felt the exhibition's theme of societal healing was dominated by post-colonialism, tribalism, feminism, immigration, race, and hair, and expressed a desire to add Palestinian actions like launching incendiary balloons or participating in violence to the narratives presented.
The exhibition prominently featured Palestinian artist Vera Tamari's clay olive trees and watercolors by Mohammad Juhha depicting a destroyed Gaza, which the author felt could have included tunnels and hostage situations. The Israeli pavilion showcased Avi Mograbi's work "Between a River and a Sea," which the author interpreted as suggesting the establishment of Israel disrupted a natural order. Another exhibit, "Nothingness of Rose" by Belu Simion Fainaru, was described as powerful, featuring a black space and dripping water, with a connection to Paul Celan's "Death Fugue."
The visitor book at the Israeli pavilion contained numerous "Free Palestine" messages, but one entry in German quoting "Death Fugue" and stating "We will never forget" moved the author's wife, Marina, who felt it was a rare sign of support. The author questioned whether art exhibitions should engage in political debate, especially when Israel is so vilified under the guise of societal healing, suggesting the Israeli representation offered a weak, universal answer. He felt Israelis were only permitted to mourn the Holocaust and warn against repeating it, but not to speak about the present.
Marina challenged the author's perspective, suggesting his narrative prevented him from seeing persecuted minorities. While trying to be open, he pondered if the West could discuss societal repair without taking sides and if, in the name of healing, narratives were being undermined. During a walk, they met Lorenzo De Castro, director of the International School of Graphics in Venice, who expressed a nuanced view, stating he would allow Israeli artists but not the government to exhibit, similar to Russia or Iran. The author surprised De Castro by identifying himself as a settler from Jerusalem, arguing that settlers' voices are silenced and demonized, and that their perspective is rational and ethical, not just fundamentalist.
De Castro was reportedly struck by this viewpoint, noting that most Israeli professors he met distanced themselves from the government and figures like Smotrich. The author declared, "I am Smotrich," which De Castro found impactful. The author felt that, perhaps indirectly, they had managed to gain a foothold at the Biennale. He also noted Anna Kamishan's ambitious work "Nabatele," a floating synagogue, and observed a Palestinian flag flying over the historical Jewish Ghetto, which he felt symbolized that while Jews could discuss past oppression, others now controlled the narrative and the ground. The author concluded that Europe, like Venice, is slowly sinking, but still serves as a platform to which Israelis have limited access.