Get Plus

Sign in to baba News

One account across the web, iPhone and Android — your subscription follows it.

or use an email code

Search stories

Type at least two characters. Results come from every newsroom baba reads.

↑↓ to move · ↵ to open · esc to close

Sign in to baba News

Sign in to keep asking. News Plus removes the daily limit.

or use an email code

Makor RishonSecurity

Defining Victory: Israel and the US Weigh Next Steps Against Iran

Translated & summarized from Makor Rishon by baba

RightCharged tone

Hebrew · 1 newsroom

Reports indicate President Trump is considering a significant military strike against Iran, potentially targeting key infrastructure. This raises questions for Israel about its strategic objectives and the definition of victory in its ongoing conflict with Iran. While military options are debated, the article suggests that continued economic pressure might be a more effective strategy to force Iran into concessions, given the high costs and uncertain outcomes of military action.

The story in 7 lines · by baba

  • President Trump is reportedly considering a significant military strike against Iran, potentially targeting infrastructure.
  • The article questions Israel's strategic objectives and the definition of victory in its conflict with Iran.
  • Potential military action could occur before the formation of a new Israeli government.
  • Iran has reportedly hardened its nuclear and missile assets in underground facilities.
  • Intensifying economic pressure is presented as a potential alternative to military strikes.
  • Iran's economy is severely strained, with hyperinflation impacting daily life.
  • The article weighs the high costs and uncertain outcomes of military action against Iran.

Amidst ongoing political developments, reports suggest President Donald Trump is contemplating a renewed, more significant military strike against Iran, potentially targeting energy facilities, nuclear sites, and infrastructure. The Wall Street Journal reported Trump conveyed this intention to Gulf states, signaling a "short and intense" war post-midterm elections. He indicated a decision would be made within two weeks. Such an operation could commence even before the formation of a new Israeli government, prompting a critical examination of Israel's strategic approach to the Iran conflict.

Amidst a confusing and often contradictory flow of information regarding the scope, targets, and timing of potential strikes, the article stresses the need to look beyond political spin and disinformation. It posits that while much of the relevant information is classified, strategic decisions should be based on known facts and past experiences. A key caveat is that this analysis assumes no immediate threat of an Iranian attack or imminent nuclear breakout, which would otherwise justify preemptive action.

Rafael Grossi, IAEA Chairman, stated he has no information on new activity at previously bombed nuclear sites, though Israeli and US intelligence may possess more. The article questions whether Israel has regained deterrence three years after the previous conflict, noting a recent avoidance of direct confrontation by adversaries but warning against complacency. It highlights that Iran learns from past conflicts and strengthens its most effective capabilities.

The primary objective for Israel in renewing the conflict, according to the article, appears to be regime change in Tehran. However, it questions the feasibility of this goal through military means, noting that popular uprisings have not materialized and the regime has shown a willingness to use force. Alternative strategies like targeted assassinations or empowering regional actors have also proven unsuccessful. The article suggests that Iran has learned from past attacks, hardening its nuclear and missile assets in deep underground facilities, posing a new challenge for conventional weapons.

An alternative strategy discussed is intensifying economic pressure to cripple Iran's economy and incite popular unrest. While the US has previously resisted targeting civilian and economic infrastructure due to global energy market concerns, Iran's inability to export oil due to sanctions has somewhat mitigated this risk. The article notes that Iran's economy is already severely strained, with hyperinflation and rising prices impacting daily life, and that continued economic pressure might force the regime into difficult concessions.

The article concludes by weighing the significant costs and unpredictable consequences of any military action, including potential Iranian retaliation against global communication lines, shipping routes, and potentially Israel itself. It questions whether the benefits of a preemptive strike, especially without a clear, achievable objective and a coordinated plan, outweigh the risks and costs. The author suggests that continued economic pressure might be a more effective strategy, forcing Iran to negotiate from a position of weakness, while acknowledging the risks of prolonged tension and potential miscalculation.

Makor RishonRight · Jerusalem

Sign in to baba News

Sign in to follow newsrooms, topics and people.

or use an email code

Sign in to baba News

Sign in to follow newsrooms, topics and people.

or use an email code

Mentioned

Open the Wire