Haredi Draft Law Opposition Driven by Political Motives, Says Rabbi
Translated & summarized from Arutz Sheva by baba
Rabbi Eliezer Shnold believes opposition to the Haredi draft law is politically motivated, aiming to topple the government. He stated that immediate, universal Haredi conscription is impractical and criticized those who previously failed to advance it. The Rabbi highlighted the logistical challenges of integrating Haredi soldiers and defended the previous "appropriate integration" order, arguing enforcement was the issue. He urged the Religious Zionist public to carefully consider political promises ahead of the elections.
The story in 6 lines · by baba
- Rabbi Eliezer Shnold claims opposition to the Haredi draft law is politically motivated to destabilize the government.
- He argues that immediate, universal Haredi conscription is impractical and hinders enlistment efforts.
- Shnold criticized opponents who previously held positions allowing Haredi conscription but did not act.
- He highlighted the significant logistical challenges in rapidly integrating thousands of Haredi soldiers.
- The Rabbi stated the previous "appropriate integration" order was sufficient, with enforcement being the key issue.
- He urged the Religious Zionist public to critically evaluate political promises before the upcoming elections.
Rabbi Eliezer Shnold, Rosh Yeshiva of the Meir Harel Hesder Yeshiva in Modiin, stated in an interview that opposition to the Haredi draft law is largely politically motivated, aiming to destabilize the current coalition government. Speaking at the "Hineni" conference in Jerusalem, Rabbi Shnold argued that the demand for immediate conscription of all Haredi men is impractical and could hinder efforts to increase their enlistment.
He criticized those leading the opposition, suggesting some had opportunities to advance Haredi conscription in past roles but failed to do so, even creating obstacles. Rabbi Shnold described the proposed law as a unique opportunity due to its extensive enlistment targets, sanctions, and the agreement of some Haredi rabbis. He cautioned that demands for immediate, universal conscription are unrealistic, stating, "When someone tells you everything now, know that he wants nothing."
While not attributing ulterior motives to Religious Zionist figures who opposed the law, he suggested many may not fully grasp the professional complexities involved. Rabbi Shnold, who has been involved in Haredi conscription issues since the establishment of the Netzah Yehuda battalion, highlighted the logistical challenges of rapidly integrating thousands of Haredi soldiers, emphasizing the need for specialized command structures and training that respects their religious needs.
He noted a growing desire among some Haredi individuals to enlist following the recent conflict, but stated that the lack of legal regulation impedes this. Rabbi Shnold also addressed the controversy surrounding the IDF's joint service order, disagreeing with the assertion that replacing the previous "appropriate integration" order was necessary. He maintained that the original order adequately addressed the needs of religious soldiers and that enforcement, not the order's content, was the issue.
Rabbi Shnold concluded by reflecting on the upcoming elections, emphasizing the importance of Jewish identity, security, settlement, and education in Israel. He urged the Religious Zionist public to critically assess political promises based on past performance and commitment to these core issues.
