Israeli Fantasy Literature Explores Divine Promises and National Identity
Translated & summarized from Israel Hayom by baba
Israeli fantasy literature is exploring the ancient question of divine promises and national identity, particularly as elections loom. Works delve into the tension between historical action and divine plans, and how Jewish mythology intersects with modern Israeli society. Authors examine the potential dangers of one group imposing its interpretation of tradition as a universal authority, questioning whether divine truth grants the right to rule and shape the lives of others.
The story in 7 lines · by baba
- Israeli fantasy literature is examining the tension between historical action and divine promises regarding the land.
- The debate questions whether perceived divine promises grant interpretive authority over earthly reality.
- Early Zionism sought to create a "new Jew" and a new state, emphasizing action and sovereignty.
- Dystopian and contemporary novels explore fears of religious states and the imposition of one worldview.
- Assaf Ashri's "Simantov" questions if divine truth grants the right to rule and shape others' lives.
- The core issue is whether absolute conviction justifies imposing one's beliefs on others.
- The choice is between allowing beliefs to coexist or to dictate others' lives.
As elections approach, a deep-seated question about who is entitled to the land and the authority to shape its future is resurfacing in Israeli society. This debate goes beyond territorial disputes, touching upon whether ancient, perceived divine promises grant interpretive authority over earthly reality. For over a century, Hebrew culture has grappled with two narratives of return and connection to the land: one emphasizing historical action through labor, settlement, and sovereignty, and the other viewing it as part of a grander, ancient divine plan.
Fantasy literature provides a unique lens to explore this tension by integrating Jewish cultural elements like angels, demons, Kabbalah, and messianic figures into modern Israeli life. Early Zionism, aiming to create a "new Jew" and a new state, championed a "muscular Judaism" as advocated by Max Nordau in 1898, re-imagining figures like Bar Kokhba as national heroes. Hebrew literature, through works like Haim Hazaz's "The Sermon," depicted a new Jewish persona, the Sabra, who actively shapes his destiny rather than awaiting salvation. However, secular Zionism often employed biblical language, secularizing religious concepts of redemption and ingathering of exiles into historical projects.
Conversely, religious perspectives, such as those of Rabbi Kook and Uri Zvi Greenberg, integrated the Zionist enterprise into a broader redemptive process. This shared reliance on ancient narratives, symbols, and memories explains how seemingly opposing camps interpret their connection to the land. Over time, these differences have evolved into ideological polarization, with Israeli literature questioning the consequences of one vision seeking to dominate the other.
Dystopian novels from 1984, like Binyamin Tamuz's "Jeremiah's Inn" and Amos Keinan's "The Road to Ein Harod," explored fears of a halachic state or a military regime. Later works, such as Yishai Sarid's "The Third," depict a return to religious national order leading to destruction. From another angle, Haim Sabato's writing preserves Eastern Jewish tradition against modernization. While both sides fear loss, one fears cultural erasure, the other the existential threat of a single religious viewpoint becoming state authority.
Original Israeli fantasy literature, though rich in myth, has often remained niche, struggling to integrate its vast source material beyond religious or folkloric contexts. Recent years, however, have seen a rise in urban fantasy attempting to weave myth into contemporary Israel. Works like Hagar Yanai's "The Whale of Babylon," Yoav Katz's "Ben Gurion Airport," and Judith Kagen's "Harseta" incorporate Jewish mythology into modern settings. Assaf Ashri's "Simantov" (2008) is highlighted as a particularly mature and daring example, posing the philosophical question of whether divine truth grants the right to rule. The novel imagines the prophet Elijah arriving not as a benevolent guest but as a zealous figure demanding a return to an absolute, pure order, willing to use violence to achieve it. Ashri challenges the leap from divine revelation to political sovereignty, asserting that metaphysical truth does not automatically confer ruling rights.
The relevance of "Simantov" to contemporary Israel lies in its exploration of how a group's interpretation of tradition can become a universally binding authority, even for those who do not share it. A secular-liberal approach, the article argues, is not about dismissing faith but about protecting the right of diverse individuals to live according to their beliefs. The danger arises when absolute conviction leads to the belief that the future belongs to them, and opposition becomes an obstacle. When absolute truth justifies coercion, exclusion, or violence in the name of a "holy cause," it forfeits its legitimacy to shape the common home. The choice facing Israelis is not just what they believe, but what they permit their beliefs to do to others, questioning whether those who believe the land was given to them have the exclusive right to rule it and dictate others' lives.