Israeli Court Recognizes Soccer Injury During Company Event as Work Accident
Translated & summarized from Bizportal by baba
An Israeli labor court has recognized a software engineer's knee injury sustained during a company-organized soccer game as a work accident. The court ruled against the National Insurance Institute, stating the event was an integral part of the employee's work aimed at fostering team cohesion and motivation. The employer's significant involvement in organizing and promoting the activity was a key factor in the decision. The injured engineer will now be evaluated for disability.
The story in 6 lines · by baba
- An Israeli labor court ruled a soccer injury sustained by Eran Tzabari during a company event is a work accident.
- The court found the game organized by Toga Networks was an integral part of work, aimed at fostering employee connections.
- The National Insurance Institute argued the activity was voluntary and private, but the court disagreed.
- Testimony highlighted the employer's pressure and encouragement for employees to participate in the event.
- The injured engineer will be referred to a medical committee to determine his disability level.
- The National Insurance Institute was ordered to pay 5,000 shekels in expenses.
The Deputy President of the Regional Labor Court in Tel Aviv, Asnat Rubovich-Barchash, has ruled that an injury sustained by software engineer Eran Tzabari during a soccer game organized by his employer, Toga Networks, constitutes a work accident. Tzabari argued that the weekly soccer activity, held in September 2023 at the Hod HaSharon Sports Center, was an integral part of his work, aimed at fostering professional connections between teams on different floors. He stated that while participation wasn't officially mandatory, management exerted pressure, and non-participation was viewed negatively.
The National Insurance Institute contended that the game was a private, voluntary activity during leisure hours, with Toga only funding half the cost. However, Rubovich-Barchash accepted Tzabari's position, citing his testimony, which was not refuted, that Toga's management organized the sports event for all employees. Tzabari testified about the importance employers in the high-tech sector place on team-building activities to strengthen employee bonds, enhance identification with the company, and boost motivation and productivity.
Shai Poltaheim, Tzabari's manager, testified that he witnessed management meetings emphasizing the importance of such events for employee motivation and building a creative, high-work-ethic workforce, crucial for success in high-tech. He added that cohesive and satisfied employees with strong company identification exhibit higher productivity.
Rubovich-Barchash noted that while employees were not forced to participate, there was "social pressure and intense weekly encouragement from management." She accepted Tzabari's explanation for the delay in seeking medical attention, stating he initially believed the injury was minor. The court ruled the soccer game was a "work-related ancillary activity," highlighting the employer's active involvement in funding, organization, promotion, and insurance, alongside a genuine interest in inter-departmental synergy.
The court ordered Tzabari to be referred to a medical committee to determine his disability level. The National Insurance Institute was ordered to pay 5,000 shekels in expenses. Tzabari was represented by attorney Levi Laviab, and the National Insurance Institute by attorney Sarah Tamam.
Mentioned
Not the same event — other stories that share this one’s people, places, or theme: background, reactions, and follow-ups.
