IDF Judge David Dvir Delivers Harsh Critiques on Dancing with the Stars Contestants
Translated & summarized from N12 by baba
David Dvir, the forthright judge on Israel's Dancing with the Stars, has delivered sharp critiques to contestants including Tom Aviv, Matan Peretz, Shi-Lee Shindler, Guy Hochman, and Bat Chen Segev as the season nears its finale, questioning their dancing abilities and potential for improvement.
The story in 6 lines · by baba
- David Dvir is known for his blunt critiques on Dancing with the Stars Israel.
- He harshly criticized Tom Aviv's cha-cha as robotic and lacking dance quality.
- Dvir doubted Matan Peretz's foxtrot would continue to impress despite progress.
- Shi-Lee Shindler was told her body isn't built for dancing despite her effort.
- Guy Hochman's jive was entertaining but lacked true dance elements.
- Bat Chen Segev's cha-cha debut lacked charm and full expression according to Dvir.
David Dvir, known for his blunt and uncompromising critiques on the Israeli version of Dancing with the Stars, has once again sparked controversy with his comments as the season nears its finale. Throughout the show, Dvir has been consistent in delivering sharp feedback, often challenging contestants' performances and their dancing abilities.
Among his most memorable critiques, Dvir harshly criticized Tom Aviv's cha-cha, saying, "I don't understand how you dare. You take your body and try to dance with it, but nothing comes out. No step was a dance. It was like a robot moving because it was told to." He also expressed concern for the professional dancer Yana, stating, "I'm a little scared for Yana."
Regarding Matan Peretz's foxtrot, Dvir acknowledged the contestant's progress but doubted the audience's support would continue, saying, "I feel your body doesn't belong to your movements. The hands aren't held behind the back. I think you are serious about your work, but the body doesn't fit what you do. What does the audience understand? I don't think this has a future."
Dvir was less optimistic about Shi-Lee Shindler's Viennese waltz, noting her effort but doubting her potential for improvement: "I see you try hard, but some bodies aren't built for dancing. Without that foundation, I don't see room for improvement."
Comedian Guy Hochman’s jive performance was described as entertaining but lacking dance quality: "I didn't come here for entertainment, I came to see dance. There was everything but dance, it doesn't work. You must dance more, otherwise, what are we doing here?"
Finally, Dvir critiqued Bat Chen Segev’s cha-cha debut, expressing disappointment despite her potential: "Bat Chen, there wasn't much charm here. Something about your body didn't speak to me. The language hasn't come out yet, even though you have all the attributes. This was your first dance? I want to see a performance."
As the season finale approaches, Dvir’s candid and often harsh assessments continue to provoke strong reactions from contestants and viewers alike.
Mentioned
The same event, reported separately by each outlet. Open a few to compare what different newsrooms emphasize — and what they leave out.
Coverage from N12
Not the same event — other stories that share this one’s people, places, or theme: background, reactions, and follow-ups.