developing· Economy· Updated
Israeli Court Rules Heirs Not Personally Liable for Deceased Lawyer's 438 Million Shekel Debt
On Tuesday, November 17, 2026, Israel's Supreme Court ruled that the heirs of the late prominent attorney Dr. Yaakov Winrot are not personally liable for a debt of approximately 438 million shekels owed to billionaire brothers Moshe and Mendi Gärtner. The ruling, delivered by Justice David Mintz alongside Justices Yael Vilner and Alex Stein, overturned a lower court's decision regarding the personal liability of Winrot's widow, Giselle, and their six children.
3 newsrooms · 1 language · sinceWhat happened
- 01The Supreme Court ruled that the heirs of the late attorney Dr. Yaakov Winrot are not personally liable for a 438 million shekel debt.
- 02The massive debt remains solely with Winrot's estate, protecting his widow and six children from personal bankruptcy.
- 03The ruling upholds an arbitration award requiring the estate to repay $37.5 million in trust funds to billionaire brothers Moshe and Mendi Gärtner.
- 04The Supreme Court overturned a lower court decision that had left open the possibility of personal liability for the heirs.
- 05The court approved the transfer of 7 million shekels in security deposits to the Gärtner brothers.
- 06The dispute arose from tens of millions of dollars entrusted to Winrot for investments, which he claimed were legal fees.
- 07The Supreme Court established that heirs do not automatically become personally liable for a deceased's debts by continuing legal proceedings.
While the Supreme Court upheld a prior arbitration award that obligates Winrot's estate to pay the massive debt, it confined the financial obligation solely to the estate itself. This prevents the Gärtner brothers from seizing the private assets of the heirs, who would have otherwise faced personal bankruptcy. The court also approved the transfer of 7 million shekels in security deposits to the Gärtner brothers.
The ruling concludes a complex civil dispute spanning over two decades. The Gärtner brothers, who are active in the diamond and real estate industries, had entrusted Winrot with tens of millions of dollars for investments, including ventures with businessman Dan Gertler. Winrot had claimed the funds were legal fees and entrepreneurial contributions. An arbitrator, retired Judge Eitan Ornstein, previously ruled that Winrot had failed to return $37.5 million in trust funds and ordered repayment with substantial interest, a sum that ballooned to 438 million shekels.
Following Winrot's death in 2018, his heirs took his place in the legal proceedings. The Supreme Court established that heirs do not automatically become personally liable for a deceased person's debts by continuing legal proceedings, noting that the heirs' personal liability had not been sufficiently litigated and could not be determined without their explicit consent.
Summarized by baba from the reports of 3 newsrooms. Updated
Latest report: Mako. Read Mako’s originalThe coverage
3 newsrooms on this story
Who covered it
- LeftNone
- Centre1
- RightNone
- Haredi1
- ArabNone
- Other1
How it broke
How the headlines differ
Israeli Court Rules Heirs Not Personally Liable for Deceased Lawyer's 438 Million Shekel Debt
