Wire

Sign in to baba News

One account across the web, iPhone and Android — your subscription follows it.

or use an email code

News Plus

Welcome, one more step

The cross-newsroom layer: who covered a story, who didn’t, and how each one worded it. Plus your own news, on every device.

Follow your news

  • Unlimited follows
  • Alerts for what you follow (in the app)
  • Story alerts (in the app)
  • Hide read stories
  • The daily brief by email

See the coverage

  • Headlines side by side
  • Who reported first
  • Every newsroom clip, from every platform
  • Every newsroom photo on a story

Go deeper

  • The whole archive
  • Your reading diet
  • Duki without the daily limit
  • The Desk: the news, spoken every hour
  • Catch Me Up, and what changed since you read it
  • The Wire

Free stays free: the live wire, Not Everywhere, the brief, five follows and five Duki questions a day.

Search stories

Type at least two characters. Results come from every newsroom baba reads.

↑↓ to move · ↵ to open · esc to close

Sign in to baba News

Sign in to keep asking. News Plus removes the daily limit.

or use an email code

News Plus · Ask Duki

Keep asking Duki

A free account gets five questions a day. News Plus lifts the daily limit.

Also in News Plus

  • The whole archive
  • Headlines side by side
  • Who reported first
  • The Desk, every hour

Breaking· Security· Updated

Ex-Military Secretary Claims Protocols Falsified; Opposition Demands Probe, Netanyahu Cites Betrayal

Retired Major General Avi Gil, who served as military secretary to Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, has alleged that officials in the Prime Minister's office falsified protocols and altered official records following the October 7, 2023, Hamas terror attack. Gil stated that Tzachi Braverman, Netanyahu's Chief of Staff, ordered a stenographer to change the recorded time of a crucial phone call on the morning of the attack from 6:40 AM to 6:29 AM. Gil also claimed that a 55-page document submitted by Netanyahu to the State Comptroller omitted crucial intelligence warnings and misrepresented discussions.

6 newsrooms · 2 languages · since

Sign in to baba News

Sign in to save this article and find it on your phone.

or use an email code

Ex-Military Secretary Claims Protocols Falsified; Opposition Demands Probe, Netanyahu Cites Betrayal
Illustration by baba

What happened

  1. 01Former military secretary Avi Gil alleged that Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's Chief of Staff, Tzachi Braverman, ordered a stenographer to alter a key call time on October 7 from 6:40 AM to 6:29 AM.
  2. 02Gil claimed that Netanyahu's office falsified protocols and submitted a misleading document to the State Comptroller that omitted crucial intelligence warnings.
  3. 03According to Gil, military intelligence received reports of suspicious signs in Gaza at 3:55 AM on October 7, but the duty officer did not wake him.
  4. 04Gil stated he woke Netanyahu at 6:29 AM to report a broad Hamas attack, and by 6:40 AM declared that Israel was at war.
  5. 05Gil confirmed that former Shin Bet chief Ronen Bar issued a war warning to Netanyahu in July 2023, but denied there was a specific warning immediately before the attack.
  6. 06The Likud party accused Gil of knowing about the attack since 3:55 AM and delaying waking the Prime Minister until 6:29 AM without providing intelligence.
  7. 07Gil asserted that security recommendations for preemptive operations and the elimination of Hamas leaders in Gaza were rejected prior to the attack.
  8. 08Opposition leaders, including Yair Lapid and Gadi Eisenkot, demanded immediate criminal investigations into the alleged protocol alterations in the Prime Minister's office.

According to Gil, military intelligence received reports of suspicious activity in Gaza at 3:55 AM on October 7, but the duty officer did not wake him because the situation was described as routine. Gil was awakened at 6:12 AM by the Shin Bet chief of staff, who reported suspicious indicators, including Hamas terrorists descending into underground facilities. Gil stated he woke Netanyahu at 6:29 AM to report a broad Hamas surprise attack, and by 6:40 AM declared that Israel was at war. Gil confirmed that former Shin Bet chief Ronen Bar had issued a general war warning to Netanyahu in July 2023, but denied there was any specific, focused warning of an imminent attack immediately before October 7.

Gil also asserted that security recommendations for preemptive operations and the elimination of Hamas leaders in Gaza were repeatedly rejected prior to the attack. He further suggested that ministerial opposition to hostage deals led to the deaths of some hostages who could have been saved and returned earlier. Following these revelations, opposition leaders, including Yair Lapid and Gadi Eisenkot, called for immediate criminal investigations into the Prime Minister's office.

In response, the Likud party accused Gil of knowing about the impending attack and failing to alert the Prime Minister earlier. The party claimed that Gil possessed intelligence since 3:55 AM but delayed waking Netanyahu until 6:29 AM, at which point they claim he failed to provide any intelligence information.

Summarized by baba from the reports of 6 newsrooms. Updated

Latest report: JDN. Read JDN’s original

The coverage

6 newsrooms on this story

Who covered it

  • Left1
  • Centre2
  • Right2
  • Haredi1
  • ArabNone

How it broke

Plus

News Plus · Who reported first

See which newsroom broke it

The order the newsrooms filed in, and how long each side of the press waited before running the story.

Also in News Plus

  • Headlines side by side
  • Story alerts
  • The Wire
  • Unlimited follows

How the headlines differ

Plus

News Plus · Who reported first

See which newsroom broke it

The order the newsrooms filed in, and how long each side of the press waited before running the story.

Also in News Plus

  • Headlines side by side
  • Story alerts
  • The Wire
  • Unlimited follows