Former Israeli Military Intelligence Chief Warns US Support for Israel Is Rapidly Eroding

Tamir Hayman, former head of Israeli Military Intelligence (AMAN) and current director of the Institute for National Security Studies, warned on Monday that the traditional bipartisan support for Israel in the United States is rapidly diminishing. Speaking at the Ynet and Yedioth Ahronoth National Security Conference in cooperation with INSS, Hayman highlighted a significant shift in American public opinion, especially among younger generations under 50. He noted that 86% of Democrats and 56% of Republicans in this age group hold negative views of Israel, with similar trends among Evangelical Christians. This shift threatens the longstanding "safety net" of US sanctions protection for Israel, which has historically prevented efforts to isolate the country internationally.

Hayman explained that the decline in support reflects broader American societal issues, including a moral and value crisis linked to progressive left-wing activism and a reactionary white nationalist movement on the right. He pointed out that antisemitism is growing on both sides of the political spectrum, with Israel and Jews increasingly viewed negatively, especially among youth who fear openly identifying as Zionist. Despite strong admiration for Israel within the US military, Hayman cautioned that political support in Washington increasingly depends on a few individuals, making Israel's position precarious.

To counter this trend, Hayman urged Israel to present a clear vision emphasizing its identity as a small, innovative state seeking peace and security. He stressed the importance of proposing a credible path toward resolving the Israeli-Palestinian conflict to restore hope and maintain international support. Additionally, he warned against neglecting ties with Europe, which remains a vital economic, cultural, and security partner.

Addressing reports of a potential US strike on Iran, Hayman expressed skepticism about the effectiveness of military action unless it produces significant, lasting change. He emphasized that Iran is unlikely to capitulate under pressure and that the costs of such strikes might outweigh the benefits. Hayman concluded by noting Israel's strategic calculations regarding Iran's nuclear ambitions and the potential fall of the Iranian regime, underscoring the complexity of the threat.

Summary: Tamir Hayman, former Israeli Military Intelligence chief, warns that US public and political support for Israel is rapidly declining, especially among younger Americans, threatening Israel's traditional protection from sanctions. He calls for a renewed vision for Israel and cautions against relying on military action against Iran without clear strategic gains.