Tel Aviv Mayor Slams "Fast Lane" Project as Traffic Solution Failure
Tel Aviv Mayor Ron Huldai criticized the government's "Fast Lanes" project, calling it a failure that worsens traffic and harms public transport. The project, featuring large parking lots and free shuttles to Tel Aviv, is underutilized and costly, with shuttle passengers costing an estimated 100 shekels each. Huldai argues it encourages private car use, lacks integration with public transit, and slows down existing bus services. He urged the government to either repurpose the facilities or reduce shuttle services to avoid wasting billions and prolonging traffic congestion.
הידיעה ב-6 שורות · תקציר של baba
- Tel Aviv Mayor Ron Huldai stated the "Fast Lanes" project worsens traffic and harms public transport.
- The project's large parking lots are underutilized, with Shapirim facility only 50% full.
- Shuttle passengers cost an estimated 100 shekels each, a figure Huldai deems exorbitant.
- Huldai argues the project encourages private car use and lacks integration with public transit.
- He claims shuttles slow down regular city buses, creating "cannibalization" of public transport.
- The mayor called for repurposing parking facilities or reducing shuttle services.
Tel Aviv-Yafo Mayor Ron Huldai has sharply criticized the government's "Fast Lanes" project, arguing it exacerbates traffic congestion and harms public transportation. In a special opinion piece, Huldai, who has 27 years of experience working with government ministries, described an unprecedented decline in public service quality, particularly in transportation planning and management. He cited the "Fast Lanes" project, which includes large parking lots in Shapirim and Rishon LeZion with free parking, Wi-Fi, cafes, and direct, free shuttles to Tel Aviv's employment centers, as a prime example of this failure.
Huldai contends that the project, despite its impressive engineering, actually encourages private car use instead of prioritizing high-capacity public transit solutions. He believes the state is investing billions in expensive, temporary solutions for private vehicles, a strategy that he argues worsens traffic, delays essential projects, wastes taxpayer money, and severely damages public transportation.
The mayor highlighted the underutilization of the Shapirim parking facility, which is only about 50% full, and noted that the cost per passenger for the shuttles is estimated at around 100 shekels, an exorbitant figure. He pointed out that existing public transport options, like buses on dedicated lanes and Israel Railways, are already competitive with the shuttles and will become even more so as congestion increases, rendering the parking facilities "white elephants."
Furthermore, Huldai criticized the lack of integration between the parking facilities and the wider public transport network, forcing users to drive to the lots. He also noted that a dedicated lane for shuttles was created by taking away a public transportation lane, hindering regular bus services. He argued that this approach, which prioritizes private cars, will trap Israelis in traffic for decades.
He also raised concerns about the shuttles themselves, stating that a shuttle carrying a maximum of ten passengers occupies space on public transport lanes, slowing down regular city buses that carry 50 passengers. This, he explained, creates a "cannibalization" of public transport, not just in terms of passengers but also infrastructure and drivers, exacerbating a known shortage in the industry. Additionally, he pointed out that the high-floor, multi-step shuttles are less accessible than low-floor city buses, negatively impacting people with disabilities and parents with strollers, and further slowing down urban transit.
Huldai concluded by calling for a reassessment of the project, urging the Ministry of Transport, the Accountant General, and the Budget Division to either transform the parking lots into efficient transport hubs or drastically reduce the number and frequency of shuttles entering the metropolitan area. He suggested canceling the planned shuttles from the Qesem parking lot to save a billion shekels and avoid disrupting the existing public transport system.
מוזכרים
לא אותו אירוע: ידיעות אחרות שחולקות עם הידיעה הזו אנשים, מקומות או נושא. רקע, תגובות והמשכים.