Brain Drain Threatens Israel's Future as Developed, Independent State
תורגם ותומצת מתוך Arab48 על ידי baba
Researchers from Tel Aviv University warn that Israel faces economic collapse and threats to its existence due to a significant increase in emigration, particularly among highly skilled professionals. The number of emigrants has risen sharply since 2019, while returnees have decreased, leading to the worst negative migration balance since 2009. This "brain drain" impacts not only the economy and R&D but also national security, as critical technological expertise departs. The trend, exacerbated by political events and affecting those aged 35-46 with children, could jeopardize Israel's status as a developed, independent state.
הידיעה ב-6 שורות · תקציר של baba
- Israel faces economic collapse and existential threats from a growing "brain drain" of skilled professionals, according to Tel Aviv University researchers.
- Emigration rates have surged, with the number of departures rising significantly since 2019, while returnees have hit a 15-year low.
- The "brain drain" particularly affects university graduates in fields like engineering, computer science, and medicine, impacting national security.
- The negative migration balance in 2023-2024 was the worst recorded since 2009, with projections indicating further increases in departures.
- Emigration is notably increasing among high-income earners and individuals aged 35-46 with young children.
- Researchers warn the trend could become a "tsunami" threatening Israel's future as a developed, independent nation.
Researchers from Tel Aviv University are warning of a potential collapse of the Israeli economy due to escalating rates of emigration, particularly among highly skilled professionals. While the current situation is not yet critical, they caution it could rapidly deteriorate.
The report, soon to be published, highlights that emigration is most prevalent among those with bachelor's degrees and higher, especially in fields like engineering, computer science, and medicine. The researchers told "The Marker" newspaper that continued emigration would severely deplete Israel's skilled human capital, which is essential for its economy.
They expressed concern that further negative shocks could accelerate the exodus, as expanding networks of Israelis abroad and the economic and social consequences of this trend could trigger more departures. The report notes that the number of Israelis returning to the country in 2023-2024 was the lowest since 2009, with a negative migration balance also at its worst since that year.
Data from the Central Bureau of Statistics indicates that while an average of 32,000 citizens left Israel annually between 2009-2019, this figure rose to 50,000 in 2023-2024, and is projected to reach 69,000 in 2025. Concurrently, the number of returnees fell below 20,000 annually in 2024 for the first time since 2009. The negative migration balance widened from an average of 10,500 in 2009-2019 to approximately 30,000 in 2024.
The emigration rate among university graduates has nearly doubled between 2019 and 2024, outpacing the overall increase in emigration. Specifically, emigration among doctors rose 1.75 times, engineers 1.9 times, and bachelor's degree holders 1.87 times. Between 2023-2025, 1,400 doctors are estimated to have emigrated, double the number from 2013-2015.
Researchers fear that the departure of top talent, crucial for society and the economy, could become a "tsunami" threatening Israel's ability to exist as a developed, independent nation. They point to countries like Turkey, Iran, Russia, Venezuela, and South Africa, which failed to recover from similar transitions. The report also raises concerns about Israel's large Haredi population, which is not highly skilled in core subjects, potentially hindering the nation's ability to cope with the loss of skilled workers. As a tech-dependent nation, Israel's primary resource is its human capital, and significant emigration could impact national security, not just the economy.
The brain drain is seen as damaging not only research and development but also national security and resilience, as Israel's scientific and technological capabilities in engineering, cyber, and computer science are vital for developing advanced defense systems and cyber capabilities. The increase in emigration was noticeable in the third quarter of 2023, prior to October 7th, with the researchers stating that election results significantly influence many individuals' decisions to stay or leave.
The rise in emigration is particularly pronounced among individuals aged 35-46 with young children, where the rate has nearly doubled. High-income earners are also increasingly represented among emigrants, rising from 24.5% in 2009 to 33.5% in 2024.
מוזכרים
לא אותו אירוע: ידיעות אחרות שחולקות עם הידיעה הזו אנשים, מקומות או נושא. רקע, תגובות והמשכים.
