Commentator Criticizes Minister Chikli for Using Fallen Son's Memory in Political Attack
Translated & summarized from Arutz Sheva by baba
Political commentator Amit Segal criticized Minister of Diaspora Affairs Amichai Chikli for sending MK Shira Shapira a post that invoked her son's death in a political argument. Segal argued against using fallen soldiers' memories in such ways but also called for Shapira to explain her party's current positions. Shapira condemned the use of her son's memory for political attacks, stating that while she welcomes criticism, it should not involve exploiting her grief or her son's sacrifice.
The story in 5 lines · by baba
- Commentator Amit Segal criticized Minister Amichai Chikli for using MK Shira Shapira's fallen son in a political post.
- Segal also stated MK Shira Shapira should explain her party's current political stances.
- Shapira condemned the use of her son's memory to attack her political views.
- The post forwarded by Chikli linked Shapira's potential government alignment to her son's death.
- Shapira stated that while she welcomes criticism, it should not involve exploiting her grief.
Political commentator Amit Segal criticized Minister of Diaspora Affairs Amichai Chikli on Sunday for forwarding a post to Member of Knesset Shira Shapira that linked her political stances to the death of her son, Aner Shapira, who fell on October 7th. Segal expressed surprise at Chikli's action, stating that it is inappropriate to involve parents, children, and especially fallen soldiers in political arguments. He argued that Shapira's son, described as a "hero of Israel," should not be used to persuade her to vote against a government reliant on Arab parties.
However, Segal also contended that Shapira herself owes the public an explanation for the perceived discrepancy between her pre-election positions and the current actions of her party. He suggested that explanations should be sought regarding her own statements and promises made during the elections, rather than involving her family.
Shapira had previously revealed that a government minister had personally sent her a post written by X user Natanel Glasner. The post sharply criticized her over the possibility of her party joining a government dependent on Arab parties, drawing a parallel between her political path and her son's heroism. The post claimed that her son stood against terrorists and that she "chooses to stand with those who give encouragement to her son's murderers."
Shapira responded strongly to the revelation, clarifying that while she does not seek immunity from political criticism due to her status as a bereaved mother, she opposes the use of her son's memory to attack her views. She stated that while she understands the pain and anger in Israeli society, discourse must remain respectful, and criticism should not demonize opponents. She emphasized that there is a limit to such attacks and that it is particularly cruel to pit a bereaved mother against her fallen son, using his memory to question her stance.
Shapira added that a government minister forwarding such words, even if not authored by him, should question his motives. She asserted that while her path may be debated, her love for the country and the price paid for it should not be questioned. She concluded by stating that her son Aner paid with his life for their ability to live together in Israel, and the least they owe him is to remember how to be human.
Keep up with
Mentioned
The same event, reported separately by each outlet. Open a few to compare what different newsrooms emphasize — and what they leave out.
Right 2
Not the same event — other stories that share this one’s people, places, or theme: background, reactions, and follow-ups.
