Regional Clusters Foster Cooperation Among Israeli Municipalities
Translated & summarized from Makor Rishon by baba
Regional clusters in Israel, operating for a decade, have fostered cooperation among approximately 180 local authorities, managing hundreds of millions of shekels annually. Primarily driven by economic needs, these clusters enable smaller municipalities to share resources and services, particularly in challenging peripheral areas. While demonstrating success in areas like waste management and economic development, a State Comptroller's report highlighted that their full potential is not yet realized, with most budgets focused on basic services. The Ministry of Interior has pledged to implement the report's recommendations and strengthen the cluster model.
The story in 5 lines · by baba
- Regional clusters unite around 180 Israeli municipalities, fostering cooperation and managing hundreds of millions of shekels annually.
- Economic necessity drives cluster formation, enabling smaller authorities to share resources and achieve scale.
- The Western Negev Cluster provides services worth 75 million shekels yearly and has secured significant development funds.
- A State Comptroller's report found cluster activities only partially fulfill their objectives.
- The Ministry of Interior plans to implement audit recommendations and strengthen the regional cluster model.
Regional clusters in Israel, established over the past decade, are fostering significant cooperation between diverse local authorities, a stark contrast to the political gridlock often seen in the Knesset. These clusters, legally recognized as inter-municipal associations, have grown into a network of 12 entities encompassing approximately 180 municipalities. They manage operations totaling hundreds of millions of shekels annually, demonstrating a successful model for inter-local government collaboration.
The primary driver for establishing these clusters is economic. With 259 local authorities in Israel, many small and under-resourced, it is often not economically viable for each to independently procure services, develop infrastructure, or compete for funding. The clusters enable these municipalities to pool resources, achieve economies of scale, save public funds, and foster growth across municipal boundaries. Notably, the most active clusters are located in Israel's northern and southern peripheries, areas facing significant challenges and lower incomes, where such cooperation is most needed and beneficial.
The Western Negev Cluster, one of the oldest, includes 12 municipalities such as the Jewish cities of Sderot, Ofakim, and Netivot, the Bedouin cities of Rahat and Kaukab, surrounding Gaza envelope councils, and the local councils of Lahavim, Bnei Shimon, and Merhavim. It provides solutions for waste collection, established a regional veterinary service, a physics excellence center, and "AgroNegev" for agricultural technology adoption. The cluster has also focused on strengthening healthcare and tourism in the Western Negev, managing services worth approximately 75 million shekels annually, saving about 13.15 million shekels in waste collection, and raising 45.5 million shekels for economic development projects.
Bella Alexandrov, CEO of the Western Negev Cluster, views these entities not just as economic tools but as models for regionalism and decentralization, countering Israel's highly centralized governance. She argues that clusters offer a more effective solution than establishing dedicated authorities for national crises, suggesting the cluster is the natural home for post-crisis recovery efforts, citing its role in implementing projects for the "Tikumah" (reconstruction) initiative in the Western Negev.
Despite successes, the full potential of these clusters remains unrealized, as indicated by a State Comptroller's report from June. The report found that cluster activities only partially fulfill their objectives, with most budgets allocated to waste disposal, sanitation, and transportation. A survey within the report revealed that a significant majority of surveyed municipalities felt the clusters contributed little to improving services or municipal efficiency, and only moderately to regional development. The report primarily criticized the Ministry of Interior for failing to finalize legislation, establish oversight mechanisms, and set clear performance metrics for the clusters.
Alexandrov acknowledges the ambiguity in cluster authority and calls for regional partnership to become a permanent Israeli policy, urging the next Interior Minister to define shared responsibilities and provide stable, long-term budgets. The Ministry of Interior responded by welcoming the audit, committing to implement recommendations, conduct satisfaction surveys, and develop performance metrics. They are also initiating a strategic move to strengthen regional clusters and promote regionalism in Israel for the next decade.