Get Plus

Sign in to baba News

One account across the web, iPhone and Android — your subscription follows it.

or use an email code

Search stories

Type at least two characters. Results come from every newsroom baba reads.

↑↓ to move · ↵ to open · esc to close

Sign in to baba News

Sign in to keep asking. News Plus removes the daily limit.

or use an email code

Kikar HaShabbatSecurity

District Court Judges Clash With Supreme Court Over Sentencing and Probation Reports

Translated & summarized from Kikar HaShabbat by baba

ReligiousCharged tone

Hebrew · 1 newsroom

District court judges have voiced strong criticism of the Supreme Court's interference in sentencing and the weight given to probation reports during professional visits. Judges in the south and center of Israel argued for considering regional crime patterns and warned against turning social workers into judges. The debate extended to the Supreme Court itself, with Justice Alex Stein agreeing with the district judges' concerns, while other justices offered a different perspective. The Judicial Authority stated the published quotes were taken out of context.

The story in 5 lines · by baba

  • District court judges criticized Supreme Court intervention in sentencing and probation reports.
  • Judges argued for considering unique regional crime patterns, especially in the south.
  • District judges accused the Supreme Court of giving too much weight to social workers' reports.
  • Supreme Court Justice Alex Stein agreed that "the streets are bleeding" and defendants should be arrested.
  • The Judicial Authority stated that published quotes were fragmented and out of context.

An unusual confrontation has emerged between district court judges and their Supreme Court counterparts, as district judges expressed sharp criticism over the Supreme Court's intervention in sentencing, arrests, and the use of probation service reports. The clashes occurred during professional visits by Supreme Court justices to district courts across Israel.

In the Southern District Court, Judge Alon Gabizon urged Supreme Court Justices Daphne Barak-Erez and David Mintz to acknowledge the unique nature of crime in the south, including agricultural crime and traffic offenses that have made residents' lives difficult. "You need to recognize that crime in the south is unique. Don't interfere," Gabizon stated. Justice Barak-Erez responded that while regional characteristics can be considered, sentencing must remain uniform, stating, "One cannot establish different sentencing norms for different sectors."

Judge Nasser Abu Taha, who grew up in the Arab community, also voiced his concerns, emphasizing his familiarity with crime patterns within that society. "I grew up in the Arab society. I know the nature of crime. If we are strict, we know why. Don't interfere," he said.

At the Central District Court, judges meeting with Supreme Court Justices Ofer Groskopf and Yechiel Kasher criticized what they called "ridiculous" court cost rulings and the significant weight given to probation service reports. District judges argued that these reports effectively turn social workers into judges, granting excessive influence to welfare officials. "In practice, you have turned social workers into judges," they told the Supreme Court representatives.

Similar concerns about probation reports were raised at the Tel Aviv District Court, where judges met with Justices Alex Stein, Khaled Kabub, and Ruth Ronen. District judges objected to being mandated to send defendants for probation reports in severe cases, arguing it's unnecessary. Justice Stein sided with the district judges, remarking, "The streets are bleeding, and the defendant should be arrested." He added that judges too rarely use the presumption of dangerousness. Justices Ronen and Kabub, however, distanced themselves from Stein's view, noting it was not the sole perspective on the issue.

The Judicial Authority responded to the reports, emphasizing the importance of professional dialogue between judges of different courts. They stated that the quotes were "fragmented and out of context" and did not reflect the full scope of discussions. The Authority added that internal discussions would not be further addressed.

Keep up with

Kikar HaShabbatHaredi · Bnei Brak

Sign in to baba News

Sign in to follow newsrooms, topics and people.

or use an email code

Sign in to baba News

Sign in to follow newsrooms, topics and people.

or use an email code

Mentioned

Related stories · 1

Not the same event — other stories that share this one’s people, places, or theme: background, reactions, and follow-ups.

Open the Wire