Israeli Coalition Talks Stall Over Netanyahu, Ben-Gvir, and War Probe
Translated & summarized from Cursorinfo by baba
Negotiations between Israel's Likud party and the "Yesh Atid" bloc for a unity government stalled on key issues including the prime minister's role, Itamar Ben-Gvir's participation, and the October 7 investigation commission. Likud insists on Benjamin Netanyahu as initial prime minister, while the "Change" bloc demands his departure. Disagreements also persist over Ben-Gvir's inclusion and the composition of a war investigation commission. The parties did agree on Israel being the Jewish national state and opposing a Palestinian state, but Gadi Eisenkot may pursue a minority government if talks fail.
The story in 6 lines · by baba
- Israeli coalition talks between Likud and "Yesh Atid" failed to resolve disputes over the prime minister, Ben-Gvir's role, and the Oct. 7 probe.
- Likud demands Benjamin Netanyahu serve as initial prime minister, while the "Change" bloc requires his departure.
- Itamar Ben-Gvir's potential inclusion in a unity government remains a major point of contention.
- Both parties agreed on Israel as the Jewish national state and opposed a Palestinian state.
- Gadi Eisenkot may seek to form a minority government if broad coalition talks collapse.
- Bezalel Smotrich urged a broad government with right-wing parties, criticizing minority government options.
Negotiations between the Likud party and the "Yesh Atid" bloc, aimed at forming a unity government, extended over four hours on Sunday, November 22, but failed to yield agreement on key issues. The talks, held at the Dan Accadia Hotel in Herzliya, concluded with a decision to continue discussions, possibly as early as Monday, though significant progress on major points remains elusive.
Disagreements center on the identity of the future prime minister, the participation of Itamar Ben-Gvir in the government, and the composition of a commission to investigate the events of October 7. Likud insists that Benjamin Netanyahu serve as prime minister initially, with a potential rotation of the role to Gadi Eisenkot. Conversely, the "Change" bloc, which includes Yesh Atid, rules out Netanyahu continuing in office after a new government is formed, with a senior representative calling his departure a prerequisite for any deal.
A substantial portion of the talks was dedicated to the controversial issue of including Itamar Ben-Gvir, leader of Otzma Yehudit, in the unity government. "Yesh Atid" representatives indicated they would not agree to his inclusion, while Likud refused to accept this demand, continuing to advocate for Ben-Gvir's participation. No compromise was reached by the end of the meeting, highlighting differing visions for the government's composition, with Likud seeking to maintain ties with right-wing parties and "Yesh Atid" opposing Ben-Gvir's presence.
Amidst these negotiations, Bezalel Smotrich, leader of the Religious Zionism party, urged the "Change" bloc leaders to form a broad government with right-wing parties, criticizing the possibility of a minority government supported by Arab parties. He argued that natural partners for such an agreement would be those who worked with the "Change" bloc leaders during the war.
Regarding the October 7 investigation commission, the parties reached a limited understanding: if a joint government is formed, they will prepare a proposal defining the commission's powers and timeline. However, the contentious issue of who appoints the commission members remains unresolved. Likud favors a commission based on mutual consent and believes a solution can be found with an "out-of-the-box" approach.
Further complicating matters, Likud indicated that an agreement on the conscription of yeshiva students into the army would require the participation of ultra-Orthodox parties. The judicial system was also discussed at a general level, without specific disagreements emerging. Likud also demanded that the "Change" bloc halt legislative initiatives during the negotiations, a request that "Yesh Atid" refused, arguing that continuing parliamentary work does not hinder trust-building.
Despite the numerous disagreements, both sides acknowledged Israel as the national state of the Jewish people and opposed the creation of a Palestinian state. These points represent fundamental political positions rather than specifics on government composition or ministerial portfolios. Meanwhile, Eisenkot retains the option of forming a minority government with Arab party support if a broad coalition proves impossible, a prospect that has already sparked a dispute, with Netanyahu publicly stating, "We cannot form a government with Ahmad Tibi!" Yair Lapid, a member of Bennett's party, countered by reminding Netanyahu of his past reliance on Arab votes and negotiations with Mansour Abbas.
Disagreements over a minority government also exist within the "Change" bloc itself, with Naftali Bennett and Avigdor Lieberman opposing reliance on Arab parties. Lieberman favors an agreement with ultra-Orthodox parties to join a government led by Eisenkot. Eisenkot himself has stated he will not allow negotiations to drag on indefinitely and intends to pursue an emergency minority government if a broad coalition fails. Bennett continues to support negotiations with Likud, urging all efforts towards a Zionist unity government led by Eisenkot.
Keep up with
Mentioned