Get Plus

Sign in to baba News

One account across the web, iPhone and Android — your subscription follows it.

or use an email code

Search stories

Type at least two characters. Results come from every newsroom baba reads.

↑↓ to move · ↵ to open · esc to close

Sign in to baba News

Sign in to keep asking. News Plus removes the daily limit.

or use an email code

Ongoing Story· Day 20

New Israeli Bloc Plans to Repeal Four Key Laws Immediately After Knesset Swears In

10 developments

Zman YisraelPolitics

Israeli Coalition Plans Swift Reversal of Judicial Overhaul Laws

Translated & summarized from Zman Yisrael by baba

CenterCharged tone

Hebrew · 1 newsroom

Israel's new coalition is planning to rapidly repeal laws enacted by the previous government's judicial overhaul using special committees. Legal experts are divided on the challenges of a swift repeal, with some anticipating court challenges and others expecting smoother progress. The urgency is driven by the risk of irreversible institutional changes and the potential loss of the current parliamentary majority needed for repeal. The debate touches upon the concept of a "defensive democracy" and lessons learned from countries like Poland and Hungary regarding the long-term impact of such reforms.

The story in 6 lines · by baba

  • Israel's new coalition plans to quickly repeal judicial overhaul laws via special committees.
  • Legal experts disagree on the potential for judicial challenges to expedited repeal efforts.
  • Urgency stems from the risk of irreversible institutional changes and a shifting political majority.
  • The debate involves the concept of "defensive democracy" and protecting institutions.
  • Lessons from Poland and Hungary highlight the difficulty of reversing judicial reforms.
  • Some laws require immediate repeal, while others may need a more thorough process.

A coalition bloc in the Knesset has decided to establish four special committees to rapidly repeal laws enacted as part of the previous government's judicial overhaul. These changes, often referred to as the "legal revolution," significantly altered the balance of power between the government and the judiciary. The urgency stems from the fact that some changes, like the alteration to the Judicial Appointments Committee, took effect on November 10th, while others, such as weakening the legal advisors' office, are slated for January 1, 2027, if not repealed sooner.

Legal experts are divided on the feasibility of a swift repeal process. Some, like constitutional law expert Dr. Roi Peled, anticipate legal challenges from the Knesset's legal advisor and the Supreme Court. Others, including law professors Suzi Navot and Tamar Hostovsky Brandes, foresee fewer significant obstacles. Critics, such as Meir Rubin, CEO of the Kohelet Forum, question the legitimacy of using expedited legislative procedures to undo laws, drawing parallels to the previous government's methods. Supporters argue that any delay risks deepening the damage to democratic institutions and potentially thwarting the repeal efforts entirely.

The debate centers on the concept of a "defensive democracy," which allows for extraordinary measures to protect the democratic system from those seeking to dismantle it. This raises a fundamental question: can a democracy adhere strictly to standard legislative procedures when attempting to rectify damage to its core institutions? The article contrasts the current situation with Poland, where thousands of judges appointed under a flawed judicial reform continue to serve, illustrating the long and complex process of rectifying such changes. It also references Hungary's recent constitutional amendments aimed at restoring democratic checks and balances after years of erosion.

The urgency to repeal is further underscored by the risk of creating irreversible institutional realities. For instance, if judges are appointed under the new committee structure before the law is repealed, their appointments may stand. Similarly, changes to the status of the Attorney General's office or the Police Internal Investigations Department (Mahash) could become more entrenched and harder to reverse once implemented. The article also highlights the political risk: the current parliamentary majority may not endure, closing the window of opportunity for repeal.

Experts suggest that while repealing laws is relatively straightforward, undoing the realities created by their implementation is far more complex. The article distinguishes between enacting laws that expand government power and repealing them to restore checks and balances, noting that the latter inherently limits the power of the current majority. The decision to repeal specific laws, such as those affecting the Judicial Appointments Committee and the Attorney General's office, is deemed urgent, while others might warrant a more comprehensive legislative process. Ultimately, the article posits that restoring previous arrangements is insufficient for long-term democratic resilience, necessitating deeper reforms to fortify democratic institutions against future threats.

Keep up with

Zman YisraelCentre · Jerusalem

Sign in to baba News

Sign in to follow newsrooms, topics and people.

or use an email code

Sign in to baba News

Sign in to follow newsrooms, topics and people.

or use an email code

Mentioned

Open the Wire