Golan Heights and Mount Hermon Ridge Status Under International Law
Translated & summarized from Mida by baba
Israel's legal claims to the Golan Heights and Mount Hermon Ridge are examined, rooted in historical Jewish connection, the British Mandate, and international law. Following the collapse of the Syrian regime in December 2024, Israel's Prime Minister declared the 1974 Disengagement Agreement void, and the IDF secured positions on the Mount Hermon Ridge. The article highlights US recognition of Israeli sovereignty over the Golan Heights and suggests extending this to other recaptured territories for security reasons.
The story in 5 lines · by baba
- Israel's control over the Golan Heights and Mount Hermon Ridge is discussed in light of international law and recent Syrian regime collapse.
- The 1974 Disengagement Agreement with Syria was declared void by PM Netanyahu following the Syrian regime's fall.
- The IDF secured positions on the Mount Hermon Ridge after Syrian army withdrawal in December 2024.
- The US recognizes Israeli sovereignty over the Golan Heights, a stance maintained by the Biden administration.
- The article argues for extending Israeli sovereignty to recaptured territories for security and historical reasons.
The article discusses the legal standing of the Golan Heights and Mount Hermon Ridge under international law, particularly in light of recent events in Syria and historical context. It asserts that Israel's claim to the Golan Heights is rooted in historical Jewish connection to the land, the British Mandate, and international legal principles like uti possidetis juris. The text highlights that while international law generally dictates borders are based on pre-independence administrative lines, exceptions and interpretations exist. It notes that prominent international jurists believed Israel had a superior right to sovereignty in the territories captured in 1967, and that Israel could have declared sovereignty over them.
The status of the Golan Heights is presented as distinct from the West Bank and Gaza. The article details how the area was initially intended for the British Mandate, with Jewish land purchases predating the 1923 Newcombe-Poole Agreement, which transferred the territory to the French Mandate. Syria's subsequent expropriation of these lands without compensation is cited as a violation of international law. Israel's application of its law, jurisdiction, and administration to the Golan Heights in 1981 through the Golan Heights Law is described, despite UN Security Council Resolution 497 deeming it void. The article emphasizes the US recognition of Israeli sovereignty over the Golan Heights under President Trump, a stance maintained by the Biden administration, and reiterated by Trump following a Hezbollah attack in July 2024.
Following the collapse of the Assad regime in Syria in December 2024 and the subsequent declaration by Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu that the 1974 Disengagement Agreement is void, the IDF has secured positions on the Mount Hermon Ridge. The article argues that Syria's current fragmented state, with territorial, ethnic, and security divisions, compromises its ability to fulfill international obligations and ensure border security. The text also mentions the strategic importance of the Mount Hermon Ridge for Israel's security, citing its observation capabilities and ability to thwart threats to northern communities. It notes that Israel has taken action to protect Druze populations from attacks and to prevent the transfer of strategic weapons from Iran to Hezbollah.
The article concludes by asserting Israel's right to self-defense under international law, which justifies its control over certain territories as long as its security is threatened. While acknowledging that self-defense does not inherently grant sovereignty, it points to the US recognition of Israeli sovereignty over the Golan Heights as a precedent. The author suggests Israel should extend its sovereignty to areas it recaptured following the 'War of the Uprising' (Mלחמת התקומה), citing the shared interests of Druze in the Golan and Bashan with Israel, the absence of a hostile population, and historical Jewish land ownership as factors supporting this. The piece is based on a Knesset event commemorating the liberation of Mount Hermon and parts of the Bashan.