Top Rabbi Advises Parents to Support Children's Outings, Not Fight Them
Translated & summarized from Kikar HaShabbat by baba
Israeli Rosh Yeshiva Rabbi G. H. Hirsch advised parents not to fight their children's social activities like restaurant outings or cabin trips with friends. Instead, he urged parents to support their children, stating that feeling parental backing prevents alienation. This guidance addresses the generational gap and communication challenges faced by many families.
The story in 5 lines · by baba
- Rosh Yeshiva Rabbi G. H. Hirsch advised parents to support children's social outings, not confront them.
- He suggested parents participate in or support children's activities to prevent alienation.
- The advice addresses concerns about seminary girls in restaurants and boys in rented cabins.
- Rabbi Hirsch believes children's core desires remain the same despite changing times.
- His approach contrasts with parental strategies of ignoring, coercing, or balancing.
A prominent Israeli Rosh Yeshiva, Rabbi G. H. Hirsch of the 'Ateret Shlomo' Yeshiva, has offered guidance on bridging the generational gap between parents and their children, particularly concerning social activities. In response to concerns raised by Rabbi Mordechai Fish, a mashgiach at the same yeshiva, regarding seminary girls going to restaurants and yeshiva students renting cabins with friends, Rabbi Hirsch advised against confrontation. He suggested that parents should instead participate in or support their children's activities, emphasizing that when children feel their parents are with them, they are less likely to distance themselves. Rabbi Hirsch believes that the core desires of youth remain the same, even if the times have changed.
The article highlights the sensitive issue of intergenerational differences, where parents may perceive their children's actions as secular or rebellious, while children view them as legitimate. This often leads to a lack of trust and communication, with children feeling misunderstood and parents feeling their children don't prioritize their well-being. The piece notes that such trust issues often stem from a lack of open communication from a young age.
Rabbi Hirsch's approach, termed 'supportive,' contrasts with other parental strategies discussed: 'ignoring' the issue in hopes of future openness, 'coercing' children into sharing, or 'balancing' by offering alternative family activities. The Rosh Yeshiva's counsel is that active parental support, such as preparing sandwiches for an outing, fosters a stronger bond and prevents alienation.