Settlement Control in West Bank Extends Far Beyond Built Areas, Researcher Says
Translated & summarized from Arab48 by baba
Settlement spatial control in the West Bank extends far beyond built areas, encompassing planning zones, roads, and open lands, according to researcher Abd al-Hadi al-Attari. While built areas cover a small percentage, the broader control system affects over 42% of the West Bank. Al-Attari uses the Nahaliel and Talamon settlements as a case study, showing how control areas significantly exceed built-up zones. Settlement expansion, particularly in Area C and the Jordan Valley, is extensive, with outposts alone controlling millions of dunams.
The story in 6 lines · by baba
- Settlement spatial control in the West Bank exceeds built areas, impacting over 42% of the territory.
- Researcher Abd al-Hadi al-Attari uses Henri Lefebvre's theories to analyze settlement expansion.
- The Nahaliel and Talamon settlements exemplify how control areas are much larger than built-up zones.
- Settlement influence extends through planning, jurisdiction, roads, and outposts, restricting Palestinian access.
- Settlement control covers approximately 71% of Area C and 91% of the Jordan Valley.
- Despite claims of settler population decline, settlement construction surged in 2025 with new approvals.
Settlements in the West Bank exert spatial control that extends significantly beyond their built-up areas, encompassing planning boundaries, areas of jurisdiction, roads, infrastructure, and open lands designated for expansion, according to settlement affairs researcher Abd al-Hadi al-Attari. In an article published by the Institute for Palestine Studies, al-Attari utilizes Henri Lefebvre's concept of 'production of space' to explain how laws, plans, and administrative decisions redefine land use and future development potential.
Al-Attari highlights that open lands surrounding settlements can be brought under settlement influence through planning or jurisdictional inclusion, impacting their usability and potentially hindering the growth of adjacent Palestinian communities. He distinguishes between the planning boundaries, or "blue line," and the actual areas of jurisdiction of local or regional councils, noting that settlement influence can stretch beyond these limits via outposts, roads, and access restrictions.
Data from the Wall and Settlement Resistance Commission in March 2026 indicates that settlement construction and associated areas of influence cover approximately 12.4% of the West Bank. However, the broader control system, including state lands, military training zones, and roads, extends over 42% of the West Bank's area. Al-Attari cites the settlement of Nahaliel and the Talamon bloc as an example, where the built-up area is about 6,200 dunams, but the area under effective settlement control, difficult for Palestinians to access, reaches approximately 15,100 dunams, with over half of this land owned by Palestinians.
Al-Attari explains that settlements function like a "cancer," with their influence spreading through roads, checkpoints, facilities, and pastures. He identifies three levels of spatial control: the built-up area (2-3% of total control), areas of influence or municipal jurisdiction (12.4%), and the broader control system (over 42%). Outposts and pastoral farms contribute to this expansion, often starting with minimal infrastructure and gradually extending their reach and control over surrounding lands.
Regarding the settlement of Nahaliel and the Talamon bloc, al-Attari found that planning documents reveal different land use intentions and future construction plans that extend towards Palestinian lands, potentially impacting Palestinian development. He notes that while direct proof of intent to encircle Palestinian villages like Kobar is difficult without explicit documents, the spatial impact of such plans on land access and growth directions is measurable.
Al-Attari states there are approximately 550 settlement sites, including 194 settlements and 330 outposts, which, connected by roads, form an integrated structure controlling land and isolating Palestinian communities. Settlement control in Area C reaches about 71% and in the Jordan Valley about 91%. Pastoral outposts alone control about 1.1 million dunams, or 21% of the West Bank. He also addresses demographic claims, noting that while some reports suggest settlers constitute 25% of the West Bank population, other indicators point to a decline in settler numbers during the recent war, despite a surge in settlement construction and approvals, including 54 new official settlements and 86 new outposts in 2025.
Mentioned
Not the same event — other stories that share this one’s people, places, or theme: background, reactions, and follow-ups.