Lieberman's Draft Law Could Reshape Israeli Coalition
Translated & summarized from Cursorinfo by baba
Negotiations are underway regarding a revised 2018 draft conscription law proposed by Avigdor Lieberman, aiming to potentially bring ultra-Orthodox parties into Gadi Eisenkot's government. The Knesset Committee on Foreign Affairs and Defense is legally reviewing the bill, which needs adaptation to current IDF needs post-October 7th. If approved by rabbis, the updated law could pressure Arie Deri's Shas party to join, though Deri reportedly prefers not to join a left-leaning government. A final agreement requires balancing Haredi demands, army needs, and legal constraints.
The story in 6 lines · by baba
- Avigdor Lieberman's 2018 draft conscription law is the basis for talks with ultra-Orthodox parties.
- The revised law could potentially lead to Shas joining Gadi Eisenkot's government.
- The Knesset Committee on Foreign Affairs and Defense is legally reviewing the conscription bill.
- Adjustments are needed to the law due to current IDF needs after October 7th.
- Haredi leaders have not yet seen or approved a final version of the proposed agreement.
- Arie Deri reportedly is not interested in joining a left-leaning government.
Negotiations between representatives of the ultra-Orthodox party United Torah Judaism and Avigdor Lieberman, leader of Yisrael Beiteinu, are progressing, centered on a draft conscription law Lieberman initially proposed in 2018. This initiative, if adapted to current needs and approved by rabbinical leadership, could potentially persuade the Shas party, led by Arie Deri, to join the government led by Gadi Eisenkot, according to "Maariv." Sources involved in the talks indicate that a formal agreement and detailed plan have not yet been presented to the rabbis. The Knesset Committee on Foreign Affairs and Defense is currently conducting a comprehensive legal review of potential revisions to the military conscription law. The 2018 bill, proposed when Lieberman was Defense Minister, is seen by the Haredi community as a basis for agreement, with the expectation that an updated version could gain rabbinical support. However, significant adjustments are necessary due to the changed needs of the IDF following the October 7th Hamas attack and the ongoing war. The committee is examining which elements of the original bill can be retained and which must be modified to align with current IDF requirements, legal precedents, and the altered security landscape.
Preparation of the revised bill involves legal analysis followed by the formation of a detailed agreement proposal. This proposal is expected to be presented by MK Yaakov Asher to the rabbinical leadership for their decision. Haredi sources emphasize that no consensus document exists yet, meaning rabbis have nothing to approve or reject, and the ongoing talks do not signify a final compromise. The challenge lies in balancing the demands of the ultra-Orthodox community, the army's needs, and legal constraints, which will determine the feasibility of gaining support from religious parties.
The potential agreement holds particular significance for Arie Deri and Shas. United Torah Judaism representatives believe that if their rabbinical leadership endorses the revised law, they could then persuade Shas's spiritual leadership to join Eisenkot's government. This would complicate Deri's position, as he would find it difficult to justify refusing participation in a government that addresses the status of yeshiva students, a key Haredi concern. However, sources acknowledge Deri's lack of interest in joining a left-leaning government, and the assessment of Shas's potential entry comes from United Torah Judaism, not Shas itself. Previous reports indicated that Lieberman's talks with Haredi parties were advancing faster than those with Eisenkot, but a finalized bill remains elusive, with parties seeking a formula acceptable to ultra-Orthodox parties and the High Court of Justice. A major obstacle has been the Haredi demand for Shas's inclusion, driven by concerns about insufficient support during conscription law discussions.
Mentioned