Dutch Court Bans BYD SUV Sales in EU Over "Defender Copy"
Translated & summarized from Hamal by baba
A Dutch court has banned Chinese automaker BYD from selling its Ti7 SUV in the European Union, ruling it infringes on the design of the Land Rover Defender. Jaguar Land Rover filed the lawsuit, alleging the Ti7's design was copied. The court imposed significant daily fines for violations and also prohibited BYD from manufacturing the vehicle in Hungary. BYD plans to appeal the preliminary ruling, while its planned 2027 launch in Israel is now uncertain.
The story in 5 lines · by baba
- Dutch court bans BYD's Ti7 SUV sales in the EU over design infringement of Land Rover Defender.
- Jaguar Land Rover sued BYD, claiming the Ti7 SUV illegally copied the Defender's design.
- BYD faces hefty daily fines of 100,000 euros for violating the EU sales ban.
- The court also prohibited BYD from manufacturing the Ti7 at its new Hungarian plant.
- BYD disputes the ruling and plans to appeal, while its Israel launch is now uncertain.
A district court in The Hague has issued an unusual order prohibiting Chinese automaker BYD from selling its Ti7 SUV in the European Union. The ruling came Friday, following a lawsuit filed by Jaguar Land Rover (JLR), which alleged that the Ti7 infringes on the design rights of the current Land Rover Defender. JLR, owned by India's Tata Motors, initiated the legal action after BYD announced on its UK website that the seven-seat Ti7 was available for order, with deliveries expected to begin in January 2027.
Following the lawsuit's filing, Dutch investigators searched BYD's offices, uncovering materials that intensified suspicions of intentional design similarities between the two vehicles. The Hague court determined that the BYD Ti7 indeed violates the registered design rights of the current Defender, which was registered in Europe in 2018. Key similarities cited by the court include a boxy silhouette with a flat roof, upright proportions, tailgate design, squared wheel arches, and a uniform body panel behind the rear passenger door.
The court rejected BYD's arguments about differences in headlights, grilles, bumpers, hoods, windows, and wheel openings, stating these did not alter the overall impression. The injunction carries significant financial penalties: BYD faces a fine of 100,000 euros for each day of violation, or alternatively, 25,000 euros per infringement, capped at 10 million euros. The order takes effect one week after the ruling, as BYD claimed no concrete plans to launch the Ti7 in the EU. The court also prohibited BYD from manufacturing the vehicle at its new Hungarian plant, slated for full commercial production in early 2027, pending a final decision on the main lawsuit.
The judge stated he lacked jurisdiction over BYD's UK operations, meaning the vehicle can still be ordered in the United Kingdom. JLR emphasized its commitment to protecting its intellectual property, while BYD expressed strong disagreement with the decision and announced its intention to appeal, asserting the Ti7 is a product of independent design work. This preliminary ruling is subject to appeal by JLR within six months. The Ti7, marketed in China under BYD's Fangchengbao sub-brand, has achieved significant commercial success there. The planned 2027 launch of the Ti7 in Israel by importer Shlomo Motors is now uncertain.
Mentioned
The same event, reported separately by each outlet. Open a few to compare what different newsrooms emphasize — and what they leave out.
Centre 2
