Ultra-Orthodox Parties Stall Coalition Talks Over Draft Law and Other Demands
Translated & summarized from Israel Hayom by baba
Ultra-Orthodox parties are reportedly stalling coalition talks with Israel's "Change Bloc" due to disagreements over the draft law for yeshiva students and other demands. Key issues include the status of Torah scholars, oversight of Haredi education, and core curriculum studies. While the "Change Bloc" suggests progress, Haredi parties claim no substantial offer has been made. Legal challenges are anticipated regarding any draft exemption arrangements, with the Attorney General having previously deemed such exemptions unconstitutional.
The story in 5 lines · by baba
- Ultra-Orthodox parties claim no substantial offer has been made in coalition talks with the "Change Bloc".
- The draft exemption for yeshiva students remains a central point of contention in negotiations.
- Other demands include oversight of Haredi education and core curriculum studies.
- Legal challenges are expected for any draft exemption agreement, with the Attorney General opposing them.
- Haredi parties seek arrangements without sanctions for Torah scholars, while others insist on universal service.
Negotiations between Israel's "Change Bloc" and ultra-Orthodox parties are yielding conflicting reports, with sources close to the bloc suggesting progress while Haredi parties claim no substantial offer has been made. The primary sticking point is the military draft exemption for yeshiva students, but other obstacles include oversight of ultra-Orthodox education, core curriculum studies, and the integration of women into the IDF.
United Torah Judaism (UTJ) insists that no proposal has been presented that can be brought before their rabbis for approval, stating their main demand is a formula to regulate the status of yeshiva students and ensure they are not considered draft dodgers. MK Yitzhak Pindrus of UTJ previously stated that regulating the status of Torah scholars would be the party's first demand in any future government. Party chairman Yaakov Asher also recently indicated a lack of understanding with the Change Bloc.
A policy paper from the "Tachlit" institute, advising Gadi Eisenkot's party, previously proposed a new framework for the draft. It suggested yeshivas play a crucial role in the draft arrangement, as their studies grant exemptions, and they effectively approve who their students are. The paper noted that yeshivas have an institutional interest in increasing their student numbers and might not send all students to the army. Without independent oversight, the paper argued, it's difficult to verify yeshiva enrollment reports. It recommended defining the role of yeshivas, their reporting duties, and an independent supervisory body, along with a clear enforcement mechanism to deter violations while maintaining proportionality and avoiding societal division.
However, a dispute has emerged over sanctions: Haredi parties demand an arrangement without penalties for Torah scholars, while the 'Yesh' party insists on universal service as a condition for partnership. Legal advisors to the Change Bloc are exploring potential solutions but express significant doubt about forming an agreement that would withstand Supreme Court scrutiny and the Attorney General's stance. The Attorney General, Gali Baharav-Miara, has previously argued that arrangements granting exemptions to the vast majority of yeshiva students are unconstitutional.
Beyond the draft, other issues are surfacing. Activists from the Democrats party criticize the potential for agreements with Haredi parties without addressing broader societal issues. They emphasize the need for oversight of the ultra-Orthodox education system, particularly regarding core curriculum studies in institutions that do not teach essential subjects. Concerns have also been raised about the impact on women's integration into the IDF within future agreements. Meanwhile, some Haredi journalists have suggested that a potential break from the right-wing bloc could lead to improved oversight of Haredi educational institutions and the introduction of core curriculum studies.
Mentioned