Health Clinic Accused of Denying Care to Yeshiva Student Over Draft Status
Translated & summarized from Kikar HaShabbat by baba
A yeshiva student in Be'er Yaakov claims a Maccabi Kupat Holim clinic secretary refused him treatment for shortness of breath, allegedly calling him a "draft dodger." The incident prompted a petition from students and intervention from the Rosh Yeshiva and an MK. Maccabi Kupat Holim issued an apology, stating such conduct is unacceptable and promising a full investigation.
The story in 4 lines · by baba
- A yeshiva student claims a clinic secretary denied him medical care for shortness of breath due to his draft status.
- The incident occurred at a Maccabi Kupat Holim clinic near the Grodna Yeshiva in Be'er Yaakov.
- Yeshiva students signed a petition, and the Rosh Yeshiva and an MK intervened.
- Maccabi Kupat Holim apologized, calling the alleged conduct unacceptable and promising an investigation.
A controversy erupted at the Grodna Yeshiva in Be'er Yaakov after a yeshiva student, who arrived at a Maccabi Kupat Holim clinic experiencing shortness of breath, claims a secretary refused him treatment because he is an "afra" (draft dodger).
The incident, which occurred last weekend, led to a petition signed by dozens of yeshiva students who are members of the health fund. The petition was submitted to the yeshiva's administration. The Rosh Yeshiva, Rabbi Tzvi Drebkin, has instructed that steps be taken to prevent similar incidents in the future. MK Yehuda Weissfish of Degel HaTorah also intervened, contacting the management of Maccabi Kupat Holim. Following his inquiry, district and fund management officials addressed the matter.
Maccabi Kupat Holim later sent a letter of apology to the yeshiva, expressing regret and stating their respect for the yeshiva students. In their response, Maccabi stated, "We view with great severity any statement or conduct by an employee that could harm an insured person or prevent them from receiving medical service due to their personal views or beliefs. Such conduct is unacceptable to us in any way."
The health fund added that since learning of the incident, they attempted to contact the student and yeshiva officials to understand the circumstances but had not yet spoken to the student directly. The matter has been transferred for review by the relevant parties within Maccabi. "If these things were indeed said, we regret it and apologize to the yeshiva's management and students. We respect them and all our insured members and strive to provide everyone with equal, respectful, and non-discriminatory medical service."