New Documentary Explores 75-Year-Old Mystery of Jews Murdering Jews in Baghdad
Translated & summarized from Maariv by baba
A new documentary by Jackie Hugi explores the 75-year-old mystery of whether Jews murdered fellow Jews in Baghdad. The film presents evidence suggesting the Zionist underground may have been involved, but lacks definitive proof. Historical context points to tensions within the Jewish community and with Iraqi society, as well as unpreparedness for mass immigration by Israel, leaving the perpetrators' identities uncertain.
The story in 5 lines · by baba
- A new documentary by Jackie Hugi investigates the 75-year-old mystery of Jews murdering Jews in Baghdad.
- The film suggests the Zionist underground may be responsible, based on journalist Baruch Nadel's archival research.
- No definitive "smoking gun" proof has been presented, leaving the perpetrators' identities uncertain.
- Tensions existed within the Jewish community and with Iraqi society due to mass emigration efforts.
- Israel's unpreparedness to absorb immigrants reportedly created significant pressure on the underground in Baghdad.
A new documentary film by Jackie Hugi attempts to prove that Jews murdered fellow Jews in Baghdad 75 years ago, reigniting a persistent mystery. Following an incident at the time, a rumor spread, originating from Iraqi authorities, that the Zionist underground was responsible. This claim became widely believed among Iraqi Jews, many of whom still think Jews were involved, either by order from Israel or on their own initiative.
Zionist movement leaders, however, claimed it was a nationalist crime, suggesting local extremists acted due to rising anti-Israel sentiment and Jewish efforts to leave Iraq. The Mossad later established two internal committees to investigate the incident, but they failed to identify the perpetrators. Numerous Israeli and foreign researchers and journalists have tried to solve the mystery over the years without success.
The documentary bases its claim on evidence from researchers and witnesses, as well as archival material. The filmmakers obtained lists compiled by journalist Baruch Nadel, who investigated the case in the 1970s. Nadel, who passed away 12 years ago, left behind a box of documents at Yale University containing his notes and collected testimonies. The film meticulously follows Nadel's handwritten pages, presenting his findings and providing historical context through interviews.
However, the film does not present definitive proof, often referred to as a "smoking gun," to support the accusation of intentional murder. While the interviewees, many of them respected individuals, offer circumstantial evidence, they struggle to provide conclusive proof. Historical research from that period reportedly dismisses the possibility of orders coming from Israel. At that time, over 86,000 Jews had registered to immigrate to Israel, but the country was unprepared for their reception due to a lack of housing and overwhelmed absorption systems. Prime Minister Ben-Gurion's government reportedly urged its envoys, the underground leaders, to be patient.
The article suggests that the situation in Baghdad was tense, with overcrowding in community shelters and a volatile atmosphere towards Jews. It posits that a Zionist underground leader might have sent a strong signal to Jerusalem to influence policy, or that a member acted alone. The author expresses a personal desire to know the perpetrators' identities, especially if they were Jewish, but concludes that Nadel and the filmmakers have not provided irrefutable evidence, leaving the case unresolved.
The film also touches upon the political divisions within the Jewish community in Iraq during the 1940s, where alongside the Zionist underground, communist and socialist movements also operated. Many Jews identified as Iraqi citizens first and opposed the mass immigration to Israel, creating a rift that persisted even after their arrival. The documentary, according to the author, implicitly points to this division and expresses disdain for the immigration project and its leaders, reflecting ongoing criticisms of the Zionist establishment.