Get Plus

Sign in to baba News

One account across the web, iPhone and Android — your subscription follows it.

or use an email code

Search stories

Type at least two characters. Results come from every newsroom baba reads.

↑↓ to move · ↵ to open · esc to close

Sign in to baba News

Sign in to keep asking. News Plus removes the daily limit.

or use an email code

GlobesPolitics

Israel's Knesset Debates 'Undo Legislation' to Repeal Previous Laws

Translated & summarized from Globes by baba

BusinessNeutral tone

Hebrew · 1 newsroom

Israel's Knesset is considering "undo legislation" to repeal laws passed by the previous government, focusing on judicial appointments and other key areas. These proposals aim to revert legal frameworks to their prior state, with some bills being exceptionally brief. While proponents cite democratic mandate and urgency, critics warn of procedural issues and damage to governmental continuity. Experts stress the need for strict adherence to legislative procedures and strong justification for such repeals, particularly concerning laws that have already taken effect.

The story in 5 lines · by baba

  • The Knesset is considering "undo legislation" to repeal laws from the previous government.
  • Key areas targeted include judicial appointments and the Attorney General's office.
  • Proposals aim to revert legal frameworks to their pre-amendment state.
  • Critics warn of procedural issues and damage to governmental continuity.
  • Experts stress adherence to proper legislative procedures and strong justification.

The Israeli Knesset is considering several "undo legislation" bills aimed at repealing laws passed by the previous Knesset, particularly those concerning the Judicial Selection Committee, the Attorney General, and communications. These proposals, dubbed "undo legislation" or "Ctrl+Z" for the statute books, seek to revert legal situations to their pre-amendment state. Professor Itai Bar-Siman-Tov defines this type of legislation as the repeal of a law from the prior Knesset, restoring the previous legal status without establishing a new one. The proposed bills are notably concise, with some containing a single clause stating the repeal of a specific law. For instance, one bill proposes to repeal the "Attorney General Law" effective January. Another bill concerning the Judicial Selection Committee, which took effect with the current Knesset's swearing-in, includes a clause to revert the "Basic Law: Judiciary" to its wording prior to its amendment.

Legal experts note distinctions in phrasing depending on whether a law has already taken effect. If a law has not yet come into force, it can simply be declared void. If it has taken effect, an operative clause is needed to restore the prior legal situation. While the substance of these "undo" efforts is clear, the precise wording may still be refined during the legislative process. However, not all repealing legislation qualifies as "undo legislation"; the latter is characterized by its immediacy and the intent to annul decisions of the previous Knesset, creating a sense of continuity in parliamentary debates.

Critics, including Minister of Justice Yariv Levin, have questioned the propriety of such rapid legislative changes, arguing that they bypass proper procedure and deny the government adequate time to formulate its position. However, proponents argue that a new Knesset holds a democratic mandate to legislate. Formally, there are no restrictions on what a new Knesset can enact before a government is formed, as it is a sovereign body. Traditionally, this period was reserved for urgent legislation or laws necessary for government formation. Legislating to remove perceived obstacles to government formation is considered more problematic and less legitimate.

The current "undo legislation" is justified by its proponents based on urgency, a rationale accepted by the Knesset's legal advisor. Nevertheless, legal scholars caution against the broad repeal of legislation from a previous Knesset, as it can undermine governmental continuity, certainty, and long-term planning. There is a concern that each new parliamentary majority might claim the previous one enacted dangerous laws requiring repeal, thereby damaging democracy. To mitigate these risks, experts emphasize the importance of adhering to proper legislative procedures, ensuring that "undo" measures do not create legal lacunae, and that the process undergoes scrutiny applicable to all legislation. Furthermore, such measures should only be employed to repeal legislation causing significant harm or violating fundamental democratic principles, with careful focus on restoring prior legal arrangements and justifying the urgency, such as preventing irreparable damage.

Regarding the Judicial Selection Committee amendment, which was legislated in the 25th Knesset but took effect with the current one (a form of delayed effect), the question arises whether its repeal should also have delayed effect. Legal experts argue the opposite: the delayed effect was intended to allow the new Knesset the option to repeal the law. The government's response to the High Court of Justice supported this view, suggesting a two-stage process where the 26th Knesset would ratify the change, giving it the opportunity to prevent judicial appointments it deems flawed.

GlobesOther · Rishon LeZion

Sign in to baba News

Sign in to follow newsrooms, topics and people.

or use an email code

Sign in to baba News

Sign in to follow newsrooms, topics and people.

or use an email code

Mentioned

Open the Wire