Chief Rabbi Bars Mixed-Gender Physical Therapy Practice
Translated & summarized from Arutz Sheva by baba
Chief Rabbi of Israel, Rabbi Kalman Bar, has forbidden mixed-gender physical therapy practice sessions for students, citing religious objections from female students. The ruling, prompted by Rabbi Binyamin Tabbai, prohibits exercises without a clear medical necessity and urges academic institutions to change their policies. Rabbi Bar emphasized that students should not have to choose between their faith and their education, criticizing institutions for failing to accommodate religious observance.
The story in 5 lines · by baba
- Chief Rabbi Kalman Bar prohibited mixed-gender physical therapy exercises for students due to religious concerns.
- The ruling addresses complaints from religious female students required to practice on male students.
- Rabbi Bar stated students should not be forced to choose between their faith and their studies.
- The decision calls for academic institutions to revise procedures to allow same-gender practice only.
- Rabbi Binyamin Tabbai initially brought the students' plight to the Chief Rabbi's attention.
Chief Rabbi of Israel, Rabbi Kalman Bar, has issued a ruling prohibiting physical therapy students from engaging in mixed-gender practical exercises unless medically necessary. The directive, prompted by complaints from religious female students, calls on academic institutions to revise their procedures, stating, "Students should not be forced to choose between their studies and their faith."
The ruling came after Rabbi Binyamin Tabbai approached the Chief Rabbi regarding the distress of religious female physiotherapy students who were required to practice on male students and allow male students to practice on them. Rabbi Tabbai explained that these exercises often involve physical contact and exposure of body parts, and after verifying there was no essential medical or professional need, he prohibited his congregants from participating. When colleges presented difficulties, he sought a halachic (Jewish law) ruling from Rabbi Bar to support the students.
Rabbi Bar affirmed that there is no medical or professional necessity for such mixed-gender exercises, deeming them strictly forbidden. He stated that institutions requiring these practices should not be attended. His decision is based on rulings from prominent halachic authorities, including the Chazon Ish, the Steipler, Rabbi Yitzchak Yaakov Weiss, Rabbi Shlomo Zalman Auerbach, and Rabbi Ovadia Yosef, who emphasized modesty in medical treatment, especially when the patient and practitioner are of different genders.
The Chief Rabbi highlighted that when such exercises are merely for academic practice and lack medical necessity, the prohibition is even more severe. He expressed concern that the close proximity and physical contact in these training sessions could lead to serious transgressions, particularly given the prolonged periods students spend together. Rabbi Bar criticized higher education institutions for failing to accommodate the needs and beliefs of religious students, questioning how individuals seeking a livelihood are forced to compromise their faith and modesty.
Furthermore, Rabbi Bar criticized the lack of protest from women's rights groups in cases where male students are also subjected to practices that conflict with their beliefs. He urged university and college administrations to amend their regulations to permit practical training exclusively between individuals of the same gender, clarifying that this is not a request to lower professional standards but to enable training in a manner that respects religious observance.