Supreme Court Asked to Ban Police Use of Horses in Protests
Translated & summarized from Maariv by baba
Israel's Supreme Court is reviewing the police's use of horses to disperse protests, a practice that causes distress and potential harm to the animals. The article argues the court should consider the inherent morality of the practice, not just legal proportionality. A recent poll shows 70% of Israelis oppose the use of horses in demonstrations, viewing it as unfair and immoral. The Supreme Court has an opportunity to advance the nation's moral standards by banning this practice.
The story in 5 lines · by baba
- Supreme Court is reviewing police use of horses to disperse protests.
- The practice causes distress and potential harm to the animals.
- Article argues the court should consider the inherent morality of the practice.
- A recent poll shows 70% of Israelis oppose using horses in demonstrations.
- The court has an opportunity to advance the nation's moral standards.
Israel's Supreme Court is currently deliberating the legality of police use of horses to disperse demonstrations. The horses are reportedly placed in volatile situations, confronting protesters, which can lead to physical injuries for both humans and animals, as well as significant psychological distress for the horses.
Legal arguments are being framed around the principle of proportionality, examining the worthiness of the goal, the means used, and the balance between them. However, the article argues that this legal framework might overlook a more fundamental question: whether the practice itself is inherently legitimate and ethical. It draws a parallel to a psychological experiment where students were tasked with a technical problem without questioning its underlying purpose, illustrating the danger of 'technocratic thinking' and moral blindness.
The piece contends that introducing an animal with feelings into a situation it's unsuited for, and forcing it into conflict with citizens exercising democratic rights, is not a legitimate action for a nation that values its conscience and dignity. The Supreme Court has previously acted as a moral compass, outlawing practices like corporal punishment in schools, and the article suggests a similar stance is needed here.
Drawing on principles of fairness, humanity, and the Jewish prohibition against causing animal suffering, the article asserts that power over animals is not unlimited in Israel. It cites Mahatma Gandhi's view that a nation's moral progress is measured by its treatment of animals. The current use of horses in protests is described as a severe imbalance, where the burden and risk to the animal far outweigh any benefit, forcing them into unnatural roles in human conflicts.
Furthermore, a recent poll by Geocartography in November 2026 indicated that 70% of Israelis consider the use of horses in protests unfair, immoral, and unjust. The article concludes by stating that the Supreme Court has an opportunity to elevate Israeli society's moral standards by banning this practice, which is seen as a test of the nation's ethical standing.